Line Out - Comments on The J Word

Comment by E

Fri, 19 Oct 2007 11:00:01 -0800

Good point JZ, but there is some usefulness to ascribing a label to a band, so as to seperate the apples from the oranges. Your job would be a lot harder if you had to describe in detail a band's sound all time, instead of using a couple words as a reference. The problem is, at what point does "band taxonomy" get out of hand? Also, there are some terms which are used only in a pejorative way, and i'm glad you pointed that out too. "Jam band" isn't a good term, neither is "freak folk" for that matter, and that's way more pejorative if you ask me. I would call them "campfire music" - or something.

Comment by Sally Struthers Lawnchair

Sally Struthers Lawnchair — Fri, 19 Oct 2007 11:05:46 -0800

I think I can smell the bass player's feet just by looking at this photo.

Comment by jz

jz — Fri, 19 Oct 2007 11:21:17 -0800

@1--you know what though? i steer clear of those shortcuts whenever i can. youre right, it makes my job harder, but i think it makes my writing clearer and more useful when i dont fall back on other peoples nomenclature.

funny, though, that "freak folk" has become a pejorative in your perspective. i dont agree w that. and there again were faced w the problem of these tags--they dont necessarily mean what we think they mean.

Comment by E

Fri, 19 Oct 2007 11:32:23 -0800

True true JZ, and you already know i'm a fan of your writing. The fact that you tend to avoid stupid genre-ish terms is good -- it makes you a critic and not a pundit.
"Freak folk" sounds kind of scary to me, honestly, so when you talk about terms that steer people away from music, this was the first example that popped into my head. Also, do they want to be referred to as freaks? Maybe Devendra does, but I don't know, the Akron guys seem nice and might not appreciate that association.
One term I really like, and as far as i know the Stranger invented (trent moorman?) is: BEARDROCK. I love it!

Comment by jz

jz — Fri, 19 Oct 2007 11:46:53 -0800

ha! beardrock rules! its like bedrock but with more letters.

few musicians care about someone elses stupid punditry--even people w beards who rock. having interviewed probably a hundred musicians by now, and asking them about tags applied to their music, most shrug it off, like its not their concern. most, however, hate the term "jam band" bc it limits their appeal to college kids and stoners.