Tuesday, February 3, 2009

Oi! Ban the Death Tax! Oi! Cut Welfare! Oi!

Posted by Paul Constant on Tue, Feb 3, 2009 at 10:35 AM

In this article, titled "Republican is the New Punk," conservative columnist Doug TenNapel (who, weirdly, is the creator of Earthworm Jim) argues that since rock and roll was "so central to the inauguration of Barack Obama," that means that, well, Republican is the new punk.

6c08/1233685782-truckcover01.jpgLefty politics are no longer the fringe and no matter if the voters knew it or not they carved lefty politics into stone. Bill Ayers became the system he once fought against. Sure, they still wear the earring and say “fuck” a lot to maintain street-cred among the academics, but now rock has taken sides — it is for the establishment. Same with journalism, the university and pop-culture. The left has become a cliché. They’re not “Arrested Development” they’re “Golden Girls” with a soul patch. Snore.

Now that the art nerds and punks just became the football jocks and prom queens, a new rebel is emerging from the wilderness. They are the new anti-establishment. One minority force bands together against every other branch of government swallowed by the Democrat octopus. The last evidence of a check or balance against the popular people are now the Conservative Republicans.

The arts have failed. They no longer keep mass culture in check with thought-provoking art that challenges the establishment. Now they’re in charge of spreading the mainstream mandate of the Liberal Vatican. There isn’t an original thought among them, just a thousand-mile stare, a blue logo and the drone-like vocabulary of emotive, vaguely inspiring chants.

We’re the new rebellion against the majority juggernaut that doesn’t take kindly to dissent. Make a fist and show them what happens when they tell you what to think, feel and believe.

If you want me to unite to your cause, then end abortion, give the people back the money they earned, fight terror, keep your hands off free speech on the radio and enable job creators to make more jobs. Until then, screw your hope and screw your change.

Um, PUNK ROCK! It's kind of cute that Earthworm Jim guy, who is the lead singer of a band named Truck, thinks that rock and roll was rebellious up until Obama won the presidency. And I have been at punk shows where the audience started passionate chants of "George! W! Bush!" I'm pretty sure they were mocking the idea of punk being rebellious. Because if Kid Rock and Ted Nugent are the generalissimos of this revolution, their battle's been lost before it's even begun.

Share via

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Newsvine
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Email
 

Comments (9) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
1
I'm sure you'll all enjoy my newest three-chord anthem about how eliminating taxes on capital gains will create jobs. 1!-2!-3!-4!-
Posted by Ayn Random and the Corporate Overlords on February 3, 2009 at 11:16 AM
2
It will by getting the government out of our lives - something punk rock started out as.
You will notice as Democrats attempt to get govt into every corner of our lives.
Posted by D on February 3, 2009 at 11:34 AM
3
@2: Sorry, wrong. Punk rock in England was a response to Thatcherism, which was categorized by a retreat from the social safety nets of Britain's total-employment society following WWII. But nice try.
Posted by Co-opting Rebellion For Simpletons on February 3, 2009 at 12:18 PM
4
Man, I loved Earthworm Jim. Finding out TenNapel is a hard-right Christianist with a victim complex makes me really sad. Same goes for Joel from MST3K, but he at least doesn't spray his whine all over his comedy work and teh internets, plus he's been actively making really funny stuff for long enough that I give him a pass. It's kinda like loving G'N'R in spite of Axl being an abusive prick.
Posted by Billy Nilly on February 3, 2009 at 1:47 PM
5
Real punks vote Republican because it's the fastest way to fuck shit up. You want anarchy? Regime change? Just vote for a succession of George W. Bush types and watch government crumble right along with roads, we can be like Zimbabwe, just give it time.
Posted by lotus eater on February 3, 2009 at 3:01 PM
6
D'oh! I am a bad geek. Joel is not the rightwinger on MST3K, it's Mike Nelson. More fuel for the fire of Joel vs. Mike arguments. Carry on!
Posted by Billy Nilly on February 3, 2009 at 3:40 PM
7
'Punk rock in England was a response to Thatcherism'
I would argue in addition to struggling against the traditionalism of that administration, it was a politicized in response to the gridlocked society manifested in piles of rotting garbage from union workers striking.
And a rebellion against the blandness of post war socialism that infantilized a culture in the name of social safety nets.
Posted by D on February 3, 2009 at 4:02 PM
8
Beyond anything else, punk rock was way more awesome before anyone started attaching it to their [marketing campaign / religion / political party] in an effort to create instant legitimacy.

If anyone cares to actually do their homework, punk rock started in America, where it was the umbrella term for a surprisingly wide range of musical styles favored by a rag tag assortment of junkies, queers, artsy fartsies and sufferers of various personality disorders (this was what made it a little thing called "fun," by the way).
Posted by Billy Nilly on February 3, 2009 at 4:31 PM
9
@8: If the Ramones count as punk's originators (and maybe they do, and maybe the MC5 and Stooges and New York Dolls before them, though I think that would be stretching it) it should be noted that their music was, initially, apolitical in nature. Joey Ramone said as far as he was concerned, "punks" were out-of-work dudes hanging out on street corners looking for something to do. So, still not at all about "getting the government out of our lives," as Mr. Punk = Ron Paul up top is suggesting. As if conservatism ever had anything to do with less government interference in ordinary peoples' lives anyhow. Newsflash: the size of the government consistently grows under conservative governments. It's just the parts of government that help people that shrink.

Although it is arguably true that letting the conservatives do whatever they want for the last 8 years has resulted in a more thorough dismantling of society than all the lip-service anarchists in the world have ever accomplished in all their years of playing guitars and getting fanciful haircuts.
Posted by Republican Music Is Young Country on February 3, 2009 at 5:37 PM

Add a comment

 

All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use