Line Out Music & the City at Night

Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Can Buy a Thrill: Steely Dan @ Paramount Theater

Posted by on Tue, Oct 13, 2009 at 12:04 PM

(Photos by Jackie Canchola.)

So, this is what Baby Boomer triumphalism and opulence look and sound like. Steely Dan won. Their fans won, too. These folks, most of them white and over 40, could afford the $60-$175 ticket prices to wallow in the gilded nostalgia of hearing Steely Dan’s immaculately conceived and executed 1977 LP Aja performed in its entirety—topped off with a generous dessert of myriad Dan hits from their artistically successful and lucrative run from 1972-1980.

I felt privileged to witness this spectacle.

steely-6.jpg

Steely Dan represent the pinnacle of a certain kind of American band: the rare convergence of genius musicians/arrangers/composers/producers doing precisely what they want and making incredible bank while doing so. Steely Dan’s brain trust, Walter Becker and Donald Fagen, had the best session players at their beck and call, plus the best studios, the best drugs, and probably some of the best groupies at their disposal during the music industry’s booming ’70s. Their music blossomed from neurotic perfectionism and came filtered through a neurasthenic Jewish soul. And hundreds of thousands of people still care enough in 2009 to shell out more money than I spend on food in a month for the honor of witnessing them. Steely Dan win.

Aja was perhaps the Dan’s last classic album, and it certainly is worth hearing all at once in a large venue with many rabid, affluent fans. The sound could’ve been sharper, especially the bass, but overall, people seemed very, very happy with what they heard coming from the 13 (!) musicians onstage and celebrated the completion of each song with ovations that wrung every cent out of that $60-$175.

Besides Becker on guitar and Fagen on keyboards, melodica, and vocals, Steely Dan consisted of a bassist, three female vocalists, a pianist, another guitarist, a four-piece brass section (saxes, trumpet, trombone), and monstrously talented drummer Keith Carlock.

After a brief, jazzy knuckle-cracking sans Becker and Fagen, the well-rehearsed ensemble cruised through Aja’s seven tracks with all the ultra-competent finesse of musicians at the absolute zenith of their formidable games (backing vocalist Carolyn Leonhart-Escoffery prefaced the Aja recreation with a placing of a needle on the record itself and turned it over and did it again after “Deacon Blues” concluded). So, yeah. “Black Cow,” “Aja,” “Deacon Blues,” “Peg,” “Home at Last,” “I Got the News,” “Josie”: You (should) know the drill. This record is the epitome of smooth jazz funk, with rock chilling in the back garden with an aged scotch whiskey most of its duration. Every surface gleamed like diamond-encrusted stars.

steely-1.jpg

Aja is sophisticated sonic pleasure incarnate, the soundtrack to the (very) good life, but tinged with a cynicism and sly wit beneath the rich, all-is-for-the-best-in-this-best-of-all-possible-worlds exterior. Aja is built to last, still rewarding after hundreds of listens, still very much alive on the stage and adaptable to the whims of its two creators. I say this even as my 18-year-old self is apoplectic with disbelief. Note to my 18-year-old self: Go to hell.

Carlock impressed most mightily, generating powerful yet subtle funk, and his handful of solos made many of us shake our heads in awed admiration. Meanwhile, bassist Freddy Washington was criminally muted; he should’ve been much higher up in the mix. Come on, it’s Steely Dan. How can sound issues even be tolerated? Guitarists Becker and Jon Herrington picked out fluid, glinting leads and piquant, spectral solos all night. The three backing singers wore short, black glittery dresses and danced very lackadaisically, probably at Fagen’s insistence.

It should be noted that “Deacon Blues,” with its beautifully watery intro and supple melancholy would never be a hit in today’s chart ecology. It’s way too ambiguous, but there’s no denying the tremulous thrill as its verses lean into the chorus. But it’s hard to imagine a line like “I crawl like a viper/Through these suburban streets/Make love to these women/Languid and bittersweet” resonating with the young masses now. Last night’s extended coda of it was a nice touch.

“Peg” probably received the wildest response and it sounded about as incendiary as Steely Dan will get in 2009. But did anyone else notice Fagen's vocal inadvertently encroaching on Herrington’s guitar solo? “I Got the News” was urgently funky yet buttery, with Carlock’s ultra-tight drumming locking it in. As a bonus, Fagen gave us some Keith Jarrett-y keyboard-god movements, as if his chordings were giving him fingergasms. “Josie” was archetypically slinky funk played as if the band were in a perpetual wink. Throughout this song—and the whole night, for that matter—Fagen’s voice sounded raspily soulful, though he’s lost a bit of range. Still, he’s not bad for 61.

After Aja was completed, Fagen told the crowd that Steely Dan had played their first gig in Paramount in 1972, opening for the James Gang. Now with the crowd even deeper in the group’s hands, Steely Dan tore through 13 non-Aja songs, including “Black Friday,” “Time out of Mind,” “Bodhisattva,” “My Old School,” “Hey 19,” and “Kid Charlemagne.” Both “Show Biz Kids” and “Do It Again” received different arrangements: with the former, they didn’t enter that unstoppable, entrancing groove until near the middle of the song instead of diving right into it; with the latter, they omitted the rococo, raga-tastic organ jam (Carlock took a typically rambunctious solo instead), which I think is the best part of the song. Nevertheless, while they were inferior to the recorded versions, Steely Dan deserve credit for messing with their formulas. Another nice deviation: playing the Supremes’ “Love Is Like an Itching in My Heart” while Fagen introduced the band.

steely-setlist.jpg

Let the record show that history may have occurred during “Dirty Work,” as the group flubbed the opening section of this sublime, heartbreaking ballad, causing Fagen to halt the song and apologize. “We want everything to be harmonically elegant for you.” Aw, what a sweetheart. But, dude, seriously—Steely Dan making a mistake? It was a miracle Fagen didn’t fire the band right then and there.

Steely Dan encored with an uproarious “Reelin’ in the Years.” Because that’s what they do—with utmost harmonic elegance.

 

Comments (26) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
Bauhaus I 1
Can't Buy A Thrill changed everything about me musically - what I liked, what I bought, what I wanted to investigate. Nothing ever sounded better or more exciting on a first hearing either...and only a fool would say that.
Posted by Bauhaus I on October 13, 2009 at 12:40 PM
2
I don't know where you were sitting, Dave, but the sound from underneath the balcony on the main floor was absolutely immaculate--including the bass. (And I'm a bassist and always get pissed off when they mix it low.) Special kudos, because that spot usually has the worst sound in the house.
Posted by Bassdropper on October 13, 2009 at 1:39 PM
3
@2
Huh. I was in row U near the center—pretty choice seat, actually. I had to strain to hear bass. Couldn't believe it.
Posted by Dave Segal on October 13, 2009 at 1:43 PM
4
I was forced by my parents to listen to Steely Dan for years and hated it. Then rediscovered them in college, and now deeply appreciate them. Thanks for this.
Posted by Ancient Sumerian on October 13, 2009 at 2:20 PM
Max Solomon 5
it's taken this Clash fan 25 years to really listen to Steely Dan. after scoring Pretzel Logic & Countdown to Ecstasy this weekend at Value Village, i now have everything but Gaucho & Royal Scam on tasty, immaculately clean vintage vinyl. including Aja on red vinyl.

oh, and splurging on Steely Dan tickets doesn't mean you're "rich".
Posted by Max Solomon on October 13, 2009 at 2:50 PM
vinylsaurus 6
My 18 year-old self was a metalhead but also loved Steely Dan. Listening to them made me feel wise beyond my years. I had a double-cassette of "Can't Buy a Thrill" and "Countdown to Ecstasy" that I played on auto-reverse until it wore out.
I'm bummed that I wasn't paying attention and missed this show. Well, maybe next time.
Posted by vinylsaurus http://www.vinylsaurus.com on October 13, 2009 at 3:25 PM
Mr_Friendly 7
I hope this leads to more coverage of perv-jazz rockers on SLOG.
Posted by Mr_Friendly on October 13, 2009 at 3:48 PM
Max Solomon 8
@6: they're playing The Royal Scam tonight (plus the 2nd half of last night's show i assume).
Posted by Max Solomon on October 13, 2009 at 4:14 PM
9
splurging on Steely Dan tickets doesn't mean you're "rich".

True, but most people at the show didn't look like they were living close to the poverty line nor had missed many meals in their lifetimes.
Posted by Dave Segal on October 13, 2009 at 4:18 PM
10
Everyone and their dog seems to be a sound expert these days.
Ever think about the possibility of the limitations placed on the mixer by the nuances of the venue?
No?..I thought not.

PS...Great lighting
Posted by JYS on October 13, 2009 at 4:42 PM
11
the way fagen flipped his lit cigarette onto the stage without a care was a pretty good moment too.
Posted by pbc on October 13, 2009 at 5:00 PM
12
As an aside, what was "Rikki don't lose that number" about? All our high-school arguments about that never arrived at a conclusive answer.
Posted by ragged on October 13, 2009 at 5:12 PM
13
And you would think that an "Expert Listener" such as yourself would know that the band did not "flub up" Dirty Work by the tuning that occurred after the stop. Maybe the band needed to tune? Maybe? As well the Bass was in the mix and sounded great. It’s amazing that some people get jobs being critics on the sole basis that they can type and post online. I think you’re more suited to critiquing fast food or pet hospitals. You also have a problem repeating yourself over and over in this article in a vain attempt to appear clever.
Posted by El Supreamo on October 13, 2009 at 5:31 PM
14
If you have to stop a song to tune your instrument, that's a flubbin!
Posted by paulus on October 13, 2009 at 5:37 PM
15
I can't wait to see them in San Francisco on the 25th.
Posted by Matth3w on October 13, 2009 at 8:00 PM
16
El Supreamo wrote:
"It’s amazing that some people get jobs being critics on the sole basis that they can type and post online"

No, it's not that but some of us - due to our own fallable senses or the (in various locations) poor acoustics of the Paramounted - experienced a somewhat "distorted" sound.
Don't take me wrong, EXCELLENT show with a very spritied Donald Fagen. I have however seen them in different venues with a much "richer" sound.
Posted by Wellcraft19 on October 13, 2009 at 9:12 PM
reverend dr dj riz 17
all this talk stuns me.. i bought every steeky dan album consecutively from can't buy a thrill through aja and have been ridiculed for it all my life. .from my clollege days in the 70's through now..not even for the grateful dead have i been so ridiculed ... . and then to saunter up in here to read all this high falootin erudition makes me feel vindicated. .granted i didn't have close a small fraction of money to spend , but if i had i would have gladly spent twice that amount to hear royal scam in its entirety.. or countdown to ecstacy or pretzel logic ( frankly aja would have been my last choice to hear live )
Posted by reverend dr dj riz on October 13, 2009 at 11:57 PM
18
Nice review except for one thing that I see over and over - ageist remarks. Yes, I am 59, and I was in my 20's when Steely Dan was big - btw, I still love them and they receive a lot of airplay around my house. Dave, you may be young now, but if you are lucky you will get older. No one ever seems to mention the age of some of the older blues greats so why is it that so many reviews of the Dan Band and other older rockers always has to mention how good they are "despite being old." It should be a non-issue. Great music is great music.
Posted by Louis on October 14, 2009 at 5:50 AM
19
Was at the Royal Scam last night. All the little glitches you mention weren't apparent. It was entirely amazing. Carlock and Herrington were awesome. Beckers vocals on "Daddy .." were a highlight. The entire night was guitar heavy, as was that album so it seems fitting. Becker and Herrington traded licks on the second half of a rocked out Green Earrings. It was a jaw dropping moment as Becker held his own and then some. For a bit of Dan mystery Don and Walt walked off for the Fez only to return and lay into Green Earrings with ferocity. Backup singers traded vocals on Dirty Work and it was a great bit as all the players were featured throughout. Anyone going on about the base being low need to realize that with Carlock ripping up the kit it HAD to be low lest we end up hearing only those two players. Expect the new Dan album to be heavy on drums.
Posted by randomcory on October 14, 2009 at 2:22 PM
20
@18
I generally agree with your point about age, but w/r/t Fagen's vocals, it seemed relevant to discuss the ravages of time.

I'm 47. Is that considered young?
Posted by Dave Segal on October 14, 2009 at 4:52 PM
21
"I generally agree with your point about age, but w/r/t Fagen's vocals, it seemed relevant to discuss the ravages of time.

I'm 47. Is that considered young?"

Age is relative, Dave. Forty-seven seems young to me, lol. However, I don't feel any different in my head than I did at 25. The old bod, however, does not respond as well .
Posted by Louis on October 15, 2009 at 5:19 AM
22
"I generally agree with your point about age, but w/r/t Fagen's vocals, it seemed relevant to discuss the ravages of time.

I'm 47. Is that considered young?"

Age is relative, Dave. Forty-seven seems young to me, lol. However, I don't feel any different in my head than I did at 25. The old bod, however, does not respond as well .
Posted by Louis on October 15, 2009 at 5:23 AM
23
"I generally agree with your point about age, but w/r/t Fagen's vocals, it seemed relevant to discuss the ravages of time.

I'm 47. Is that considered young?"

Age is relative, Dave. Forty-seven seems young to me, lol. However, I don't feel any different in my head than I did at 25. The old bod, however, does not respond as well .
Posted by Louis on October 15, 2009 at 5:24 AM
24
Oops, I apologize for the double posting.
Posted by Louis on October 15, 2009 at 5:28 AM
25
Wow. That show on Tuesday night (played all of The Royal Scam instead of Aja) is still resonating in my brain. The whole band was so on the whole night and Fagen is nothing short of genius. It was such an honor to watch him in action. I was really surprised at the median age of the audience--I'm 30 and I felt like one of the youngest people there by far. Took my mom since she's been exposing me to the Dan since I was a tyke. Only "low" point, if there was one, was that just toward the end of the show, when I was thinking, "That's so cool that they didn't play Reelin' in the Years, since it's such a radio "favorite" and far from one of my faves...they came back for an encore and played one song: Reelin' in the Years. Boo, but amazing show overall!
Posted by yeahfontaine on October 15, 2009 at 8:38 PM
26
Very well written review. I think I was sitting right in front of you, Dave. I recall a couple people behind me talking about The Stranger just before the show. When compared to the past two Steely Dan shows I've been to (one at Chateau Ste. Michele, one at White River), the sound was wishy-washy. From what I've read, this is not an uncommon description of the acoustics at the Paramount. Still it was a great show at the most initimate venue I've ever seen them in.
Posted by Colin Clifford on October 16, 2009 at 5:15 PM

Add a comment

 

All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy