Line Out Music & the City at Night

Wednesday, February 24, 2010

ER Don Sounded Better than Four Tet; Nobody Danced

Posted by on Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 11:30 AM

I hate the idea that "Seattle crowds don't dance"—that we're uptight, that we're too white, that we're no fun, that we're just too much of a "rock" town—because I've seen Seattle crowds tear a dance floor the fuck up time and time again, for disco, for techno, for house, for dance-punk. But if you wanted anecdotal evidence for the old stiff, standing still Seattlite stereotype, you couldn't have done better than last night's sold-out Four Tet show at Chop Suey.

ER Don had the early opening set, and anyway they were on more of a cerebral, jazzy tip, so it was no surprise the crowd was mostly polite head nodding for them. But then Nathan Fake came out to a rapidly filling room and lead his set with hard-punching, up-tempo kick drum—to still no response whatsoever. By the time Four Tet went on, the room was so packed that even if people had wanted to move (which, again, it didn't seem like they did), they might have had a tough time of it. Still, for a sold-out show, the energy level was just ridiculously low.

(It just occurred to me: this album is kind of Four Tet's biggest crossover album into the world of "indie"/pitchfork canon, right? Kind of a sister record to that new Pantha Du Prince album. Could that crossover, and its resulting generalist audience be to blame for the lackluster crowd participation?)

So, fine—tough crowd. How was the music?

Locals ER Don frankly stole the show, with both the best sounding set and the best live setup. ER Don's Robert Nelson records his own live electric/acoustic instrumentation into his trusty Akai MPC sampler and then chops his recordings up live to great effect. Last night, he added a Moog analog synthesizer and a laptop (sequencing the synth, I'm guessing) to his usual setup, he had his different instrument outputs routed through the appropriate amps—guitar samples through guitar amps, bass through a bass amp, etc—and he was joined on live drums by Tyler Swan of Foscil/Truckasauras. The result was the most full, live sounding set than I've ever heard from ER Don, eschewing jarring fragmentation for cohesive jams. The guitar and bass sounded like they were being played by phantom musicians onstage, the analog synth was bright and slippery with portamento. It all sounded less like a producer edging towards a full band by adding a drummer and more like a full band condensed and evoked via MPC. They really made themselves a fine match for Four Tet's eclectic and expert sound—there were jazzy, off-kilter loops; there was motorik guitar riffing; there were miniature echos of Battles' weirdo prog funk (call them Skirmishes?). And it all sounded clear and powerful, with the bass rattling the windows.

Nathan Fake played frippy, pretty techno that alternated between kinetic minimal and sweeping trance. At first, as noted above, it was anchored to a heavy, pounding bass beat, but after several minutes of dishing that out to an arms-crossed crowd, he dropped it and played a couple passages of beatless, free-floating melodic synth parts. He picked it back up for the end of his set, but I'm not sure how it went over.

Sadly, Four Tet had maybe the worst sound of the night. Whether due to the natural baffling provided by a fully crowded room or just a bad mix, his set sounded muffled and quiet, the bass rumbling but not rattling, the highs and mids lost in the murk. Now, I don't expect headphone-quality sound every time I go to a live show, but music as detailed and delicate as the stuff on his excellent new album There is Love in You demands a clearer mix than it got last night. Disappointing.

Anyway, here's an oldie but a goodie for the squares who don't dance:

 

Comments (11) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
Andy_Squirrel 1
What I learned from the show: This whole DJ Laptop on a stage crap absolutely has to stop. Especially when you don't even have the time to make us visuals that can be shown via projector behind the blandness that is their stage presence.

As far as dance energy, why should I fucking dance if the twat on stage can't even be given the time to look up from his screen?.....he could've teleconferenced that shit in. Hell, the crowd could've just watched from home on their computers while he transmitted a pseudo live show via streaming video....let's just cut the middleman out (chop suey)
If guitar players, drummer & synthesists can play an instrument & interact with the crowd & give us some eye contact the least that these DJ fucks can do is strap their Laptops or remote sequencers to their hip and dance around (maybe hire some sexy men and women to do a coordinated dance on stage). I think Four Tet even tried to say something to the crowd once but Chop Suey didn't even bother to hook up a mic so we could hear.
Its just 100% unadulterated laziness all around.
I've seen basement Ukulele shows that felt more interactive and danceable than anything i heard last night!

we need some pop sensibility up in this electronic music scene, WAKE UP WORLD.
Posted by Andy_Squirrel on February 24, 2010 at 4:37 PM
smiller555 2
Well that's funny - I danced my ass off at that show, and so did the 20-30 people around me. Yeah, there was plenty of that head-bobbing bullshit going on around us but slowly and surely we overcame their lameness and the last quarter of the show was like any good Sunday at the Rebar - lots of smiles and good dancing. From where I was standing, front and center, it sounded pretty damn good, if a little quiet at first but after a bunch of us yelled for it to be louder they turned it up. I loved Four Tet live. I hope he plays at Neumo's next time so all the lamesters can look down at the dancers from the balcony while the rest of us have a good time.
Posted by smiller555 http://smiller555.com on February 24, 2010 at 4:51 PM
3
Four Tet's new album is subdued and not dance-inspiring. Not bad office background music, but it's not terribly surprising to hear that his live show his time around didn't inspire much dancing.
Posted by K3 on February 24, 2010 at 4:52 PM
4
@1: The idea that you're meant to be really watching the DJ at a dance/electronic event is a pernicious one, unless we're talking explicitly about some "turntablist" type shit. There often isn't anything to watch, but that's kind of the point—you're meant to be dancing, you know, with other people, maybe making eye-contact with/eyes at them. I do think the Chop should have had a better light show, though. Makes me wonder what happened to their old LED rig.
Posted by Eric Grandy on February 24, 2010 at 4:53 PM
5
@2: I never made it back up front after Fake, sadly, and everywhere I was it sounded bad and no one seemed to be moving at all. Glad it picked up towards the end for you.

@3: It's subdued, sure, but plenty of the new album features some subtly pumping, funky grooves ("Love Cry," "Sing," "Plastic People").
Posted by Eric Grandy on February 24, 2010 at 4:59 PM
josh 6
The new Four Tet is a surprisingly good gym album, too. The last time I saw him, I'm pretty sure that he brought a light show and projections.
Posted by josh http://www.sciencevsromance.net on February 24, 2010 at 7:40 PM
7
People were going apeshit at the SPITS show.

Nary an LED display or laptop in sight.

Strange.
Posted by Jeff on February 24, 2010 at 10:44 PM
I'm 85 Years Old 8
Personally, I thought staring at a guy working his laptop was awesome but, then again, I just love going to my office job.
Posted by I'm 85 Years Old on February 25, 2010 at 8:07 AM
More, I Say! 9
Ugh! So true! My cohorts and I were commenting on the utter awkwardness of a mostly-hetero dance crowd. Too crowded, and way too awkward. Maybe I've been spending too much time with the twinks, isn't the point just to dance? Why does every straight girl act like I'm trying to hit on them, and why does every straight guy take a bit of friendly dancing as an invitation to get gropey? Can't we just dance?

But yeah, the dancing was horribly awkward and lame. My small bubble did the best we could.
Posted by More, I Say! on February 25, 2010 at 10:15 AM
Nordic 10
@ Andy

The problem with Four Tet's performance wasn't that he was performing via laptop (he wasn't DJing btw) it was the complete lack of continuity and energy, which has everything to do with the performer, not the format. I can't tell you how many incredibly boring rock and hip hop shows I've walked out of for the same reasons. Some producers and bands simply aren't good performers. Four Tet is one of them. I've seen Four Tet on four separate occasions now and have always been disappointed. The fact that the sound was bad and there were no visual elements (i.e. projections, stage props, lighting, etc) didn't help.

As for the crowd, this show is proof that indie kids are definitely picking up on good underground dance music (Four Tet is #4 on KEXP) I just hope Four Tet's performance didn't leave too bad a taste in their mouths.
Posted by Nordic http://www.myspace.com/nordicsoul on February 26, 2010 at 1:55 AM
11
I must be an idiot. I loved that show all around.
Posted by dave5646 on March 30, 2010 at 2:20 PM

Add a comment

 

All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy