Line Out Music & the City at Night

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

Embrace The Uncool, The Compact Disc

Posted by on Tue, Jan 24, 2012 at 4:01 PM

Monks - 'Black Monk Time'

Something's in the 2012 air, as two people — apparently unaffiliated with each other — post about the poor, downtrodden, caught-between-two-favorite-formats medium that is the CD, on the same exact day.

Read the excerpts after the cut:

First, John Schooley with 'I Come Not To Bury The Compact Disc, But To Praise It':

CDs get a bad rap. Bashing the compact disc while praising vinyl has been the choice of the cool kids for awhile now, but it seems to be more about appearances than about the intrinsic value of either format.


I'm grateful to the CD. I'm not a dick toward it. Don't be so high and mighty about vinyl, you ungrateful bastards.


If you really like music you end up having to be able to play just about anything, because there is always some stuff you'll never hear otherwise. Just as I bought vinyl because that was the only way to hear certain things that hadn't been reissued on CD, I bought CDs because some of the releases on CD were of things that were so rare, I never would have been able to find a copy of the original vinyl release. Or, if I had, I wouldn't have been able to afford it. CD reissues performed a valuable service by putting impossible-to-find records in the hands of us regular folks.


The mid-1990s to mid-2000s were actually a golden era for CD reissues.


They cleaned up and remastered recordings, they hunted down unreleased tracks, they got knowledgeable people to write informative liner notes. They dealt with our ridiculous copyright laws, and the major labels (and sometimes, reluctant artists) who owned the rights to the material, and who were reluctant to let it see the light of day again. Without the good work of these people in the pre-iPod era, I either wouldn't have heard a lot of the music I love, or I would have had to pay outrageous collector-scum prices to hear it. In fact, I think it is safe to say that we owe the current richness of the vinyl reissues we now enjoy, in part, to the wave of CD reissues from previous decades.


As the era of the compact disc closes, we should afford it in passing the respect that it deserves, and allow it to live out its final years with respect and dignity.

And then Rob Manuel with the similarly titled 'In Praise Of CDs':

I've been experimenting with CDs again. In my month or so of CDs here's what I've learnt:


CDs end — this is a good thing. Say you type your favourite act into Spotify chances are it'll keep playing until you're sick of it. This is quite a negative emotion to be associated with your favourite music. 'Get it off, my brain is going to explode.'


CDs are cheap. My local charity shop sells them for £1. Playing pot luck is a fun cheap hobby. Amazon has amazing deals on with 5 for about £10.


CDs are like buying MP3s with a physical back up.


Put a CD in a player and it'll still be in the player when you next enter the room. This encourages repeat listening. Repeat listening makes music familiar — and that's how it becomes your favourite music.


Every single CD case — I can take them off the shelf and associate a memory with it. The Björk single I bought in Mike Lloyds in Wolverhampton for £1 in 1994 — I used to buy singles as I had very little money. The Sisters Of Mercy CD I accidentaly stole from the library (I took back the cover and didn't realise I had the disc until years later).


If you pile up the CDs on your shelf the spines are readable and they say 'listen to me'. They remind you of what they are and ask you to play them.


CDs don't pause between tracks like your iPod/Spotify. This matters on albums that are meant to run together. Say Dark Side Of The Moon. These records are BROKEN by this tech. If I was Roger Waters I'd take a shit in Apple's office and refuse to stop shitting until this was fixed.


The medium is the message. The CD says, 'I covet this precious artifact'. The computer file says, 'This is disposable data'.

 

Comments (11) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
Grant Brissey 1
I like to swim in the vast oceans of low-priced used CDs.
Posted by Grant Brissey http://www.thestranger.com/seattle/Author.html?oid=23414 on January 24, 2012 at 5:17 PM
Estey 2
Those reissues of the mid-90s to mid-00s are nothing to sneeze at. I'll take box sets like The Jam one (everything they ever fucking recorded on five CDs!), a stack of CDs from Infinite Zero, Soul Jazz, etc. over a lot of digitally mastered LPs without the amount of tracks, booklets of liners, etc. Vinyl is great but I have no problem with the compact disc when it has to take no prisoners on career overviews, and certain classics and their back stories.
Posted by Estey on January 24, 2012 at 6:26 PM
Grant Brissey 3
What he said too.
Posted by Grant Brissey http://www.thestranger.com/seattle/Author.html?oid=23414 on January 24, 2012 at 7:26 PM
4
That first blog you quoted, and comment #2, are right. Mid 90's-00's CD reissues were great! But doing that kind of work is expensive, and now that "information wants to be free" good luck seeing that again.

It was costly and time consuming to find the tapes, get top-notch audio engineers to remaster them and make them sound good, and have knowledgeable writers write good liner notes, or graphic designers put together a nice package - none of that is going to happen if it's just going to be for streaming on Spotify. Any stuff that didn't get the deluxe reissue treatment during the CD heyday now probably never will. There's probably tons of stuff in the vaults that's great that will never get heard if there's no money in it.

If you actually care about music, and aren't just a format snob who only likes vinyl or a techno utopian who thinks it should all be given away for nothing, this is a big loss.
Posted by harry partch on January 24, 2012 at 8:31 PM
Grant Brissey 5
@4: It's still happening. Check out Rhino Handmade, for example. I'm sure there are others I can't think of right now.
Posted by Grant Brissey http://www.thestranger.com/seattle/Author.html?oid=23414 on January 24, 2012 at 8:39 PM
Matt from Denver 6
CDs don't pause between tracks like your iPod/Spotify.


Don't know about Spotify, but iPods haven't paused like that for the last six years. He must still have a really old one.
Posted by Matt from Denver on January 24, 2012 at 11:33 PM
in-frequent 7
cds are inexpensive, tangible, sound good, last, and don't require too much care. i like cds.
Posted by in-frequent on January 25, 2012 at 12:23 AM
Greenwood 8
CDs aren't quite like "buying MP3s with physical backup" because CDs actually sound better than MP3s (more comparable with lossless formats). CDs sound better than vinyl too. And by "better" I mean objectively better (though you might have to possess a certain quality of stereo to perceive it). If you subjectively prefer vinyl, fine--in many instances I prefer the sound of a naturally or artificially distorted guitar--but that doesn't mean that a more nuanced sound is being reproduced in an analog signal. In the last couple decades CDs are sounding better than ever, so go ahead, sell your CDs. That'll mean more for me to buy at cheaper prices.
Posted by Greenwood on January 25, 2012 at 7:09 AM
LEE. 9
Wow, Schooley's article sure is defensive.
Posted by LEE. http://redeadening.blogspot.com on January 25, 2012 at 8:44 AM
cosby 10
@5: Numero Group's re-release series is amazing. The amount of research and attention to detail that goes into each release is astounding. Anyone who listens to one of their compilations without reading the liner notes is doing themselves a great disservice.

There are many other labels with meticulous re-releases. Finders Keepers is always excellent and Soul Jazz still releases compelling stuff to this day (there is one that comes out Friday in fact called "Voguing: Voguing and the House Ballroom Scene in New York City 1989-92" that looks criminally dire).
Posted by cosby http://www.myspace.com/cosbyshownights on January 25, 2012 at 9:06 AM
Man With Hat 11
The most available (Cheaper, transportable, transferrable) format is the one that will prevail. Which is it: digital files or discs?
Posted by Man With Hat http://manwithhat.bandcamp.com on February 11, 2012 at 11:55 PM

Add a comment

 

All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy