Line Out Music & the City at Night

Thursday, August 16, 2012

Sometimes, I Kinda Miss Meg

Posted by on Thu, Aug 16, 2012 at 11:50 AM

Carla Azar, shredding in the Peacocks
  • Jo McCaughey
  • Carla Azar, shredding in the Peacocks

"My only complaint about The White Stripes was that the band wasn't composed of two Meg Whites." Everett True said this on his (amazing!) website Collapse Board, and it was this bold statement that popped into my head as I watched Jack White perform at WAMU Theater the other night. He was backed by The Peacocks, his all-female band (when I saw him at Sasquatch a few months ago he was backed by the all-male band The Buzzards. Intent on keeping live performances as unpredictable and fresh as possible, he doesn't announce until the day of the show which of the two backup bands will be performing.) The standout player in the Peacocks was the brilliant Autolux drummer Carla Azar, her ferocious drumming scaled back a bit at times for the distinctively simple parts of the White Stripes songs, bringing to mind the Everett True quote. Even though I enjoyed the Sasquatch performance more, primarily because I was able to get up closer and get a look at what a madman he is on stage, it felt as though he had more of a connection with the Peacocks (not to mention the visually powerful sight of Jack White surrounded by these vivid musicians in light blue dresses and light blue lights).
Jack White and the Peacocks, courtesy of Jackwhiteiii.com
  • Jo McCaughey
  • Jack White and the Peacocks

There were rumors that he was sick, having cancelled his secret Seattle pop-up show due to exhaustion. Though the backup singer picked up more of his vocals than I expected, the nine song (!!!!) encore begs to differ. One of the best shows I've seen this year! And while I don't necessarily agree with Mr. True's assessment (although I love the sentiment!), I used to find it really annoying when people complained about Meg's ultra-minimal drumming ("What he needs is a real drummer! He's such a great guitar player!!"). His solo album is less like his other ventures in Dead Weather and The Raconteurs, and now that he has a "real" drummer, Blunderbuss feels like an extension of a White Stripes album with pro-Nashville instrumentation to back it up. It's great, but similar enough that it feels like something is missing...maybe a Meg or two?

 

Comments (4) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
bunnypuncher 1
I've argued in favor of Meg til I'm blue in the face. The one saving grace is talking to other (non metal) drummers, they always understand.

I didn't know Carla was in one of his backing bands! That first Autolux records is one of my faves of the decade, and watching them live was always just an excuse for me to watch her wail on a kit. She's fantastic.
Posted by bunnypuncher http://twitter.com/princess_wolfie on August 16, 2012 at 1:10 PM
Baby Blue 2
I never thought I would miss Meg as much as I do. I loved, loved, loved this show and thought the (haunted-looking) ladies were fantastic (Carla blew my mind) but I think Meg's perfectly imperfect voice compliments Jack's in a way that Ruby's just doesn't. There were times when the switch from Jack to Ruby felt almost abrasive which is a shame in that she's such a great talent in her own right.
Posted by Baby Blue on August 16, 2012 at 1:26 PM
3
Meg was the reason I could never, ever get behind the White Stripes. I get that White is brilliant and a genius player and raw/primitive things can be really fantastic, but Meg just plain sucked, and sucked the life/groove/momentum out of those songs. When they were just a novelty act on Sympathy For The Record Industry, it made sense. But as he started writing songs that were less raw, she never evolved past that garage band mentality. I'm personally thrilled that she's out of the picture, and I hope we never have to hear Meg White hit another drum. All of you fuckers arguing otherwise are out of your minds.
Posted by Casual_Observer on August 16, 2012 at 5:24 PM
Bree Mckenna 4
@3 No way, her super minimal style is what made the White Stripes' sound special, and much of his set the other day was made up of songs she has left a mark on. And those songs rocked harder with her on drums, its the facts.
Posted by Bree Mckenna on August 17, 2012 at 2:55 PM

Add a comment

 

Want great deals and a chance to win tickets to the best shows in Seattle? Join The Stranger Presents email list!


All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy