

I still can’t get my head around Dirty Projectors’ madly growing popularity. Don’t get me wrong: I’m happy a band with such a thorny sound can pack a club like Neumos (I arrived just as the band were walking onstage and instantly hit a solid wall of humanity). But when you break down the group’s component parts, they don’t add up to typical ’00s commercial success (critical plaudits, yes, but those don’t normally lead to rabid, large fan bases).
Led by Dave Longstreth—who strikes me as Generation Y’s David Byrne, right down to the chicken-like head-bobbing and intense, skinny-professor stage demeanor—the New York sextet boast three female singers (Amber Coffman, Angel Deradoorian, Haley Dekle) who “ah” and “oh” with a kind of creamy-white gospel passion, but arranged in rococo, doo-wop configurations. Their and Longstreth’s oft-falsetto’d smart-Caucasian emoting wriggle over quasi-highlife guitar figures and crazily metered, Bill Bruford-esque drumming from Brian Mcomber.

Their songs corkscrew in unexpected directions and defy easy head-nodding, while the melodies similarly move with the unpredictable trajectory of a knuckleball pitch. They often sound like Talking Heads and King Sunny Ade tussling in a Cubist sculpture garden; not exactly a formula for mass popularity, but damn if Dirty Projectors aren’t accruing a steadily growing, seriously receptive audience.
Longstreth came onstage solo to croon while picking left-handed on his right-hander’s guitar (I think the tune was “Like Fake Blood in Crisp October”), a sweet, low-key appetizer before the rest of the band joined him for a sparse, spindly Afropop-inflected piece wherein Dirty Projectors demonstrated their skill for making oblong song structures somehow seem elegant. “No Intention” put forth the group’s trademark halting funk with “Robert Fripp goes to Mali” guitar progressions contrasting with the ultra-white, primly formal vocal gymnastics. “Temecula Sunrise” was all controlled explosions tempered intermittently by a tensely languid lilt (Mcomber was a freakin’ animal on this track).
After a long pause for some guitar restringing, Deradoorian sang the conflicted romantic number “Two Doves” and then Nat Baldwin brought out his standup bass for “Spray Paint (The Walls),” in which they transformed the Black Flag song into a spare, mellow ballad. The one-two-three punch near the end of “Remade Horizon,” “Stillness Is the Move,” and “Useful Chamber” elevated the show to a higher level, with the latter sounding like a lethal combo of “Psycho Killer” and “Take Me to the River,” all stoic menace and exhilarating tension.
The rhythmic and mellifluous “Gimmie Gimmie Gimmie” closed the set proper with its hiccupping Laurie Anderson voxing and roller-coaster dynamics, then Dirty Projectors encored with “Fluorescent Half Dome,” a blue-toned, wistful ballad that made me think of Spain (the band, not the country), something I’ve not done in over a decade. The gig ended with the night’s most splenetic track—“Knotty Pine,” I think, a collab with Byrne from the Dark Was the Night compilation.
This set was enjoyable, but somehow it didn’t seem as celebratory and revelatory as the last one Dirty Projectors did at Chop Suey. This tour seems to be going on forever, and it would be nice to hear some new DP material. Nonetheless, the crowd ate it up. Next stop: the Showbox—or maybe even the Paramount, with the way things are going for this lovably odd band.
Photos by Kristen Blush, more after the jump.

The first disappointing thing was that no one was wearing a costume. Not in the audience—plenty of good get-ups there—but onstage. Sure, Broadcast and Atlas Sound were here on tour, and maybe it’s hard to get a costume together on the road, but c’mon. You’d think Bradford Cox would at least put on one of his old dresses or something. But no.
Cox wasn’t entirely without the holiday spirit, though. “Who’s got the best costume,” he asked between songs. “Tiger? You’re just wearing a striped shirt!” He spotted a girl dressed up as an apple with a worm poking out of it, asked her onstage, and awarded her free merch after the show for winning the first round of this impromptu costume contest. “That’s the best costume I’ve ever seen.”
Beyond the lack of costumes, it turns out that Atlas Sound and Broadcast—while certainly spooky—were kind of a bad match for Halloween. Both bands put on a fine show, but both were pretty subdued, making alternately formless or just mellow music. Even “Walkabout,” the poppiest, friendliest thing on the Atlas Sound’s recent Logos was played at a somnolent half-speed, despite the band’s occasionally energetic dual drummers, in what felt like an obvious missed opportunity to kick things up a bit. The whole set was kind of limp and noodly, and it all sounded like watching a band play in a fishtank (though not always in a bad way). The mood just didn’t seem to click with the relatively ramped-up, ready-to-party crowd.
Cox admitted as much with his winking between song banter. After the twangy, junkie cowboy number “Criminals,” Cox joked about switching things up “before we get too Austin City Limits…don’t think I don’t know.”
“Did you think this was gonna be spooky,” he asked. “Me too, but I can only be myself. I was born spooky, but I've recently become less spooky...shopping at The Gap, Whole Foods…next thing you know, they came and took away my fog machine and all my dresses. But there's one thing they can't take away from me”—and here, Cox paused to stomp on his delay pedal, so that the next word, “Dub!” echoed out appropriately. He kept riffing in a funny, fake dancehall patois as the band warmed up into the next song.
He asked the audience, “trick or treat,” and provided one of each: a rousing run through the morbidy but upbeat “Sheila” and a rendition of Broadcast’s “Teras in the Typing Pool” aided by that band’s Trish Keenan. Cox brought another costumer—a reveler in gothic bride drag—onstage for a round of applause, and then brought a guy with some kind of pan flute onstage to jam. He told a story about teaching Kim Deal how to replay one of her own songs, concluding, “We're gonna do cannonball by the Breeders now—I wish. Just more melancholy bullshit.” After which they actually played a winningly ascending jam before ending with the downer “Attic Lights.”
Broadcast burned through my good will for them with like 30 minutes of ambient noise and spooky sound effects, made slightly interesting by the strobing eyeball mandala projected on a video screen behind them and by the detachment of TK’s voice from her physical form by way of looping and delay (voices detached from forms = hauntology!). Still, when they finally kicked into the catchy, song-like “Corporeal,” with its drum machine snare crack, bass guitar and buzzing synths, the screen switching to saturated color for what looked like an endless zoom through a brain’s synaptic connections, I was spent. Hearing Truckasaurs echoing out of the Havana parking lot as I left made me think I may have missed the better Halloween party, huantology be damned.

There's really not that much that needs to be said about The Gossip, en generale, at this point. Detractors of the band are few; general consensus is that they fucking rock, and if you don't like them, they don't care. "The Gossip will never die; the gossip will never diet," touts one of their various bios.
So here's the specifics. Gossip played last night at the Showbox and if you missed it, I'm sorry. It felt communal somehow, the entire room moving as one unit, one mass brain, starting slow, ratcheting up in intensity, spilling out into the street satiated at 12:36am.

A couple years back, a close friend suggested to me that when a fight breaks out at a hardcore show, the bands immediate response should be to break into "It's Clobberin' Time," a 45-second-long intro track written by legendary New York hardcore band Sick of it All. Perfect fighting music.
This was tongue-in-cheek, of course. In reality, it's usually quite the opposite that ends up occurring onstage.
"Hey stop it," shouted Polar Bear Club vocalist Jimmy Stadt from the Chop Suey stage on Sunday night, during the bands supporting set on the Bridge Nine Tour. He had just witnessed a small scuffle that lasted no more than 30 seconds. "We're a sing along band, no fucking fights. This is technically my job, so don't fuck with me on stage. Don't fuck with me while I'm at work."
To be fair, Polar Bear Club might not be the hardest-core band you can picture (their sound leans closer to the Get Up Kids than Infest), but they certainly play on the hc team.
With the choice of Polar Bear Club, Strike Anywhere, and Crime In Stereo as the three top-billed bands (supported by anthemic Baltimore hardcore band Ruiner) for Bridge Nine Records' first official label tour, the label has cemented its transformation from proprietors of mainly raging, pissed-off East Coast hardcore (Death Before Dishonor, No Warning, Outbreak) to a mixed bag label with just enough saccharine (Polar Bear Club, New Found Glory) to be Warped Tour and Hot Topic friendly.

"Well, it's official," said Jeremy Enigk between songs at the Paramount on Friday night. "We are Sunny Day Real Estate, back from a long sleep." It had been 15 years since the band last played Seattle with its full original line-up, the quartet responsible for the band's landmark mid-90s albums Diary and LP2, and they seemed genuinely happy—and humbled—to be there onstage again. This was the final night of a warmly received reunion tour, and the band were in fine form, sounding like they hadn't aged a day since their sudden split in 1995. Enigk greeted the crowd with just a "wow, hello," before the band launched into "Friday" and "Seven," the opening tracks, respectively, of their sophomore and debut albums. It was a hell of a way to start the triumphant homecoming show.
The concert concentrated on those two records, those featuring the "classic" line-up, although the band also made room for material from their late-90s incarnation as a trio as well as a pretty stunning new song written since the band's regrouping this year. Throughout, they proved themselves to still be masters of that old loud-quiet-loud, of contrasting and conflating emotions—a kind of ecstatic sadness alternating with rage and calm. They're also clearly a product of their time and place, though, as much textbook emocore as they are at times almost "grunge" or "alternative rock," Enigk's voice approaching the dreaded "yarl" when he really strains it screaming.
Enigk didn't speak much between songs (he’s always been a dramatically soft-spoken, often unintelligible frontman), but when he did, he was both exceedingly gracious, thanking the crowd (and saying cheers) repeatedly, and businesslike about guiding the crowd through the set: “This song is called ‘Grendel.’” “How about a song from How it Feels to be Something On? A’right, cheers.” “So, we’re gonna go back to Diary for a bit. Cheers, thanks.” Guitarist, vocalist, and co-lyric writer Dan Hoerner—whose big smile throughout the show made him look like the happiest guy on that stage—was more effusive: “I have to ask myself, is this really happening? It is; it’s amazing.”
But the band were plenty emotive in song. Enigk gently swayed as if tethered to the microphone or contorted his (weirdly delicate) face with screams during the band’s many climatic crescendos. SDRE may cite U2 as a significant musical influence, but there's a world of difference between the bands' live personas—whereas Bono goes for outsized messianic poses; Enigk comes across as a penitent disciple, almost monkish with his bald-shaved head. Backing him, William Goldsmith pounded and reached behind his drum kit, Nate Mendel swivelled a little stiffly at the hips (a move you may recognize from a few Foo Fighters videos), and the whole band rocked out, head-banging or at least nodding hard on the heavier riffs.
About their new song: It featured a bright, arpeggiated guitar line (maybe a little reminiscent of “Baba O’Reily”?), a slow-churning rhythm that erupted into a huge drum roll, and Enigk singing lines about “falling out of grace,” “falling deeper,” and finally, optimistically, “crawling out hell,” with Enigk concluding, as if to sanctify the band’s reunion and hint at more new material to come, “it’s getting sweeter, I can tell.” It was a truly promising new song.
Things peaked with the epic "In Circles," the first song of the band's (obviously obligatory) encore. Enigk sang, "sincerity/trust in me," and it really felt like this was a band unfrozen from a time before irony—they're a big, shamelessly emotional band, and you really get the feeling that they believe every word*. "Running down," maybe, but this was without question a victory lap.
Here's the set-list:
1. "Friday"
2. "Seven"
3. "Shadows"
4. "Song About an Angel"
5. "Grendel"
6. "Guitar and Video Games"
7. "Iscarabaid"
8. "Theo B"
9. "47"
10. "5/4"
11. NEW SONG
12. "Spade & Parade"
13. "Sometimes"
(encore)
14. "In Circles"
15. "48"
16. "J'Nuh"
*Speaking of belief (and Segal has written about this before), whatever religious convictions Enigk may express in song, Sunny Day Real Estate's music is strong enough to not only bear them, but to even sort of translate them, at least on some kind of emotional level, to a godless heathen such as myself. This is the difference between these guys and, say, Owl City.
Photos by Blush Photo; more after the jump.
One of the things barely addressed in this profile of Why? last week was, admittedly, bandleader Yoni Wolf's sense of humor—it's there in his songs as much as are any straight-faced existential concerns, undercutting their seriousness and adding some much needed levity to the proceedings. Eskimo Snow may be their least cut-up, most somber album to date, but live, that sense of humor still expands from self-deprecating to full-on clowning.
"What's up now, bitches," was Wolf's greeting to the Vera Project. Introducing Eskimo Snow's restrained album opener "These Hands" following Alopecia track "Song of the Sad Assassin," which culminates live in an almost free-jazz freakout, guitar squealing away, bass popping with unexpected funk, Wolf told the all-ages crowd, "this next one's like a comedown, like you've been snortin' 'cain, you've been snortin' bumps all night, and this is the comedown." When multi-instrumentalist (and Seattlite) Doug McDiarmid wished a kid in the crowd a happy 18th birthday, encouraging folks to slap him "on the tuccus," Wolf added, "we're gonna fuck him in the tuccus later." Then he mentioned he'd been jogging today and gave a shout out to Olympic Fitness. He said that last night they played Anacortes and "Anacortes was talking about Seattle, and it wasn't all positive—they think they're better than you" (boo, Shelbyville). His last words pre-encore were, "in closing, we wanna pledge allegiance to deez nuts."
The band also alleviated any potential gravity by just rocking the fuck out, turning what might sound dour and doom-laden on record into massively cathartic workouts (further lightening the mood was Wolf's hopping and spinning around the stage, his advanced "jazz-hand" techniques, and his stretching during longer instrumental passages). Josiah Wolf on drums was, as usual, a flurry of fro and limbs, pounding out time and adding ready-to-burst drum rolls to several songs. Especially enlivening was the addition of Fog's Andrew Broeder on guitar and Mark Erickson on bass. Erickson's bass was a constant, heavy anchor; Broeder's guitar went from fried riffing to wah-wah wetted pecking, and he also provided, along with McDiarmid, on-point background vocals, helping to recreate some of the multi-tracked layers of the band's albums.
Highlights included: the stage lights going blood red during "Song of the Sad Assassin" as Wolf sang, "then your face turned red/as you said to me..."; the sing-along chorus and electrified outro of "The Vowells, pt. 2"; the syncopated drums (and again, full sold-out crowd sing-along chorus) of the morbidly romantic "These Few Presidents"; Wolf's brief beatboxing on "Gnashville"; the rocking climax of "Into the Shadows of My Embrace"; the encore of "Yo Yo Bye Bye" and (!) the "big kid tested motherfucker approved" Hymie's Basement jam "21st Century Pop Song," which ended with Wolf and Broeder trading ridiculously rapid fire syllables.
Here's the setlist:
"Against Me"
"Song of the Sad Assassin"
"These Hands"
"The Vowels, pt. 2"
"These Few Presidents"
"January 20 Something"
"Gnashville"
"On Rose Walk, Insomniac"
"Into the Shadows of My Embrace"
"One Rose"
"This Blackest Purse"
"A Sky For Shoeing Horses Under"
"Simeon's Dilemma"
(encore)
"Yo Yo Bye Bye"
"21st Century Pop Song"
Mount Eerie and No Kids kind of combined forces last night, with Phil Elverum drumming for the Vancover BC band, adding slightly looser and occasionally thunderous rhythms to their refined piano pop, and No Kidders Julia Chirka and Nick Krgovich playing keyboards alongside Elverum's electrified metal riffing and dual drummers for Mount Eerie. No Kids' set concentrated on what must be newer songs, which were generally slower and more subdued than the often poppy numbers on their excellent debut album Come Into My House. The band played a couple songs off that album, including a rousing rendition of "Halloween." Mount Eerie more or less played new album Wind's Poem in its entirety, and it sounded more engaging than I've ever heard it, all wind-screaming feedback (and wind-whistling from Elverum and co.), rhythmic thrum, slow-motion metal riffing, and Elverum, quiet and meek, singing in the middle of all that storming sound. For their last song, he asked the audience if it should be a quiet number or a loud one; the answer was unanimous and resounding: "LOUD!" Elverum obliged.
(Photos by Jackie Canchola.)
So, this is what Baby Boomer triumphalism and opulence look and sound like. Steely Dan won. Their fans won, too. These folks, most of them white and over 40, could afford the $60-$175 ticket prices to wallow in the gilded nostalgia of hearing Steely Dan’s immaculately conceived and executed 1977 LP Aja performed in its entirety—topped off with a generous dessert of myriad Dan hits from their artistically successful and lucrative run from 1972-1980.
I felt privileged to witness this spectacle.

Steely Dan represent the pinnacle of a certain kind of American band: the rare convergence of genius musicians/arrangers/composers/producers doing precisely what they want and making incredible bank while doing so. Steely Dan’s brain trust, Walter Becker and Donald Fagen, had the best session players at their beck and call, plus the best studios, the best drugs, and probably some of the best groupies at their disposal during the music industry’s booming ’70s. Their music blossomed from neurotic perfectionism and came filtered through a neurasthenic Jewish soul. And hundreds of thousands of people still care enough in 2009 to shell out more money than I spend on food in a month for the honor of witnessing them. Steely Dan win.
Aja was perhaps the Dan’s last classic album, and it certainly is worth hearing all at once in a large venue with many rabid, affluent fans. The sound could’ve been sharper, especially the bass, but overall, people seemed very, very happy with what they heard coming from the 13 (!) musicians onstage and celebrated the completion of each song with ovations that wrung every cent out of that $60-$175.
Besides Becker on guitar and Fagen on keyboards, melodica, and vocals, Steely Dan consisted of a bassist, three female vocalists, a pianist, another guitarist, a four-piece brass section (saxes, trumpet, trombone), and monstrously talented drummer Keith Carlock.
After a brief, jazzy knuckle-cracking sans Becker and Fagen, the well-rehearsed ensemble cruised through Aja’s seven tracks with all the ultra-competent finesse of musicians at the absolute zenith of their formidable games (backing vocalist Carolyn Leonhart-Escoffery prefaced the Aja recreation with a placing of a needle on the record itself and turned it over and did it again after “Deacon Blues” concluded). So, yeah. “Black Cow,” “Aja,” “Deacon Blues,” “Peg,” “Home at Last,” “I Got the News,” “Josie”: You (should) know the drill. This record is the epitome of smooth jazz funk, with rock chilling in the back garden with an aged scotch whiskey most of its duration. Every surface gleamed like diamond-encrusted stars.

Aja is sophisticated sonic pleasure incarnate, the soundtrack to the (very) good life, but tinged with a cynicism and sly wit beneath the rich, all-is-for-the-best-in-this-best-of-all-possible-worlds exterior. Aja is built to last, still rewarding after hundreds of listens, still very much alive on the stage and adaptable to the whims of its two creators. I say this even as my 18-year-old self is apoplectic with disbelief. Note to my 18-year-old self: Go to hell.

The Horrors are a Neil Gaiman dream of a rock band: all tailored black trenchcoats and blazers and toothpick-skinny slacks and improbably giant black hair, like human Q-tips had been used to clean all of London's sootiest chimneys. They're a sharp looking bunch—one of their t-shirts is just a picture of a stylish looking low-cut boot, and sure enough the band members whose shoes I could spy were all wearing gleaming black leather boots or dress shoes. Lead singer Faris Badwan alternately brooded and paced around the stage, hung from the microphone like a coat on rack, or shook like the mic had suddenly started shocking him—often, at climactic moments, he would throw his arms out towards the crowd like he was casting a spell.

Who/whatever funds their shoe shopping has also laid out for some pretty nice, you know, musical gear—all the usual, plus an impressive array of synthesizers and a pedal-board roughly the size of my apartment. It all gets put to good use crafting the band's shadowy shoegaze sound, which in concert tended to be slightly more raucous and less restrained than on record, some subtleties sacrificed in favor of a more overpowering sonic assault.

The echoing carnival organ riff and buzzsaw guitars of "Who Can Say" sounded great, as irresistible as on record, whereas "New Ice Age" just sounded overbearing and blunt. "Mirror's Image" was good and haunted, especially Badwan's vocals, but some of the engrossing interplay between the upper-fret basslines, the smeared guitars, and the insistent keyboards got lost in the live translation. I can't recall if I heard them play "Three Decades," but if they did, it was with something less than the awesome, My Bloody Valentine-echoing guitar sheen of the recorded version. Overall, I guess I prefer the band on record; the live show was leaving me cold enough that I split at the first sign of a slow song (I understand I missed a cover of Suicide's "Ghostrider"—damn—and presumably also their set/album-closing motorik epic "Sea Within a Sea"; I'm listening to the latter on headphones right now and it sounds just great).

A word about the crowd: I can't remember the last time I've seen so many goths intermingling with odd, colorful club kids. All these NME readers coming out of the woodwork/batcaves! Well done, Seattle.

As for opening act Japanese Motors, let's cut to the Vice Records-signed band's t-shirts:
Eh, ok. Plenty of that stuff around these days, but Japanese Motors do it in a manner that's just entirely unconvincing. Like if washed-out surf garage weren't happening right now, they'd switch to the next thing without skipping a beat—no crime, but you didn't get much of a sense of investment.
Add to that the fact that they were such bright, sunny daylight to the Horror's night, and it made for a rather blah opening act. Best thing I saw them do was a cover of Wire's "Outdoor Miner," complete with Blur-ry British accent.
Photos by Kristen Blush; many more after the jump.
“This guy sounds like Soundgarden Shreds,” my +1 said, referring to the popular, mocking YouTube phenomenon, as a lanky white guy (aka Water Beds) drummed and triggered downtuned guitar from his iPod (I think) through a stack of Soldano amps. To me, he sounded like GodHeadsilo, with his rumbling drums and gut-punch dirges, with a little truculent Killdozer churn and burn thrown into the equation. Whatever the case, dude’s a one-man post-grunge expulsion.
Seattle guitar/bass/drums trio Bronze Fawn seemed to be fixated on that revered post-rock axis of Mogwai, MONO, and Explosions in the Sky—which would be great if this were 1997; but it’s 2009, and Bronze Fawn haven’t really added any new wrinkles to this style of rock, in which surprising dynamics and exceptional instrumental prowess are crucial for avoiding torpor. Unfortunately, Bronze Fawn’s Sturm und Drang instrumentals, for all their pendulum swings from majesty to contemplation, were more ponderous than thunderous. Their buildups and breakdowns just weren’t extreme or interesting enough to challenge their post-rockin’ heroes—who, honestly, can be pretty dull themselves at times. The crowd stood stock still in cross-armed solemnity and appreciation as Bronze Fawn ground on with heads-down earnestness. It was boringly beautiful and beautifully boring.
(An aside about the crowd: It was the most stoic—and dude-intensive—I’ve seen in a while [since Sunn O))), maybe?]. Hardly any energy radiated from it, which posited a chicken/egg question: Were people lethargic because of the music emanating from the stage, or was the musical excitement flattened due to a dearth of audience chi? Or was it a combo of both? I dunno, but something’s awry when my note-taking and moderate headnodding are the most demonstrative actions at a gig. Yeah, it was a Tuesday night, but still...)
Polvo started late, due to issues with the sound (Croc sonic guru Jim Anderson was conspicuous by his absence). The North Carolinians worrisomely tinkered with the amps and instruments; Ash Bowie and Dave Brylawski looked frustrated, even disgusted while testing/tuning their guitars—not an auspicious omen.

Saturday night's Undertow/Unbroken Northwest reunion show at El Corazon was not only a celebration of Undertow and the impact the band had on the hardcore scene in the ’90s (and beyond, really), but it was also, in a way, a celebration of Brian Redman's life, the local musician who died last week in a tragic scooter accident. Redman played in Trial, 3 Inches of Blood, and Left With Nothing, and the music he helped make impacted just about everyone in that room in one way or another. They were taking donations for his family at the door, and nearly every band on the bill took a moment to say kind words about Redman and the audience cheered and applauded each time, proving he will be missed, but never forgotten.
For weeks leading up the show, there were rumors that there was going to be a very special guest jumping on the bill—those rumors proved true after Strain's set. Before Unbroken played, Converge, who were played earlier that night at the WaMu Theater with Mastadon, took the stage. They praised Undertow for being one of the reasons they're where they are today, and burned through a set of about eight mostly older songs.
When I saw Unbroken in Chicago earlier this year, it was the first time I had ever seen the band and only the second time the band had played since breaking up in the mid ’90s. The first time they reunited, it was to play a benefit show for their former guitar player, Eric Allen, who committed suicide a few years after the band broke up. Chicago's performance was charged with emotion and passion and impossible to top. So on Saturday, they had more fun with it. They were clearly playing one more time for Undertow, who wouldn't have wanted to reunite without Unbroken being a part of it, and they put forth an honest effort. But it felt pretty obvious that they wanted their last show to be in Chicago.
The highlight of the night was, as it should've been, Undertow. Undertow's music may be a frenzied, pissed off tantrum (and they played it so fucking well!) but singer John Pettibone was surprisingly jolly all night. In fact, everyone in the band was having a good time—occasionally exchanging grins and funny faces as they played. As kids jumped on stage and ran in front of Pettibone to stage dive, he splashed them with the contents of his water bottle and giggle to himself the same way an old man would when turning on the sprinkler in his front yard just as the neighbor kid ran over to fetch an overthrown baseball. He called out old friends from the audience and thanked them for being there—at the show and in his life. He dedicated songs to both Brian Redman and Eric Allen, and he credited Undertow and Unbroken for being the only bands at the time who seemed to understand what hardcore was about and were smart enough to "know when to fucking break up."
The energy in the room was so positive (despite the half-dozen or so angry dudes security had to drag from the venue throughout the night), and only once did things threaten to get ugly: in the middle of one of Undertow's songs, three security guards formed a small circle at the edge of the pit. While flashing their flashlights down to the ground, they yelled for people to move aside. The pit was ugly. I've never seen so many bodies piling on top of bodies at El Corazon—feet were connecting with faces, heads were smashing into heads, arms were tangling with arms and bending in directions arms probably shouldn't bend—and by the looks of things, something went horribly wrong. Pettibone saw the mass of security from the stage and stopped the band from finishing the song to make sure everyone was okay.
"What's going on?" he yelled into the mic from the stage. The band and crowd were silent—for a second, everyone looked over, worried that a broken face or busted leg or unconscious body was about to be lifted out of the crowd. There was a little more scuffle, a few more seconds of silence, and then one of the guards yelled "He lost his glasses!"
"GLASSES!?!?" Pettibone shouted with disbelief. They retrieved the lost spectacles from the ground, then he laughed, everyone cheered, and the music started up again. And right before they played their lost song, Pettibone promised "This is it. This is the last song." And of course everyone, went back to going fucking crazy.
Some friends have set up a memorial fund for Brian Redman's family. Click here for more information.
Photo by Paul Israel, from the Stranger's Flickr Pool. You can see many more amazing shots from the show here.
To supplement Eric's post on his Decibel highlights, here are some of mine from days 3 and 4, written in serious post-fest hangover mode.
Sat. Sept. 26 Sole Repair
Spacetime Continuum (aka Jonah Sharpe): When I arrived, he was in the midst of some slate-gray Arctic ambience that was incongruous with the sunny 70º weather. Gradually, he let in some gently undulant rhythms, and things got narcotic and subaquatic, like Basic Channel on Quaaludes. Things became very beautiful near the end with a muted, melancholy guitar motif spangling above the frigid, stolid tower of dub rhythm. Overall, Sharpe crafted timeless, classic chill-in music.
Sat. Sept. 26 Neumos
Nosaj Thing achieved a brilliant balance between elegant melodies and rugged, glitchy rhythms (and weirdness and accessibility) with his hiphop of the near future (I predict he’s really going to blow up in 2010). His set had incredible dynamics, changing up every 45 seconds or so, but not in a jarring or annoying way.
Megasoid (aka Sixtoo, left-field hiphop producer renowned for his recordings on Ninja Tune, Vertical Form, and anticon.) peddled some chunky, gritty business, somewhere between ruffneck dancehall and glitch-hop. It was alpha-male bass music done with great finesse.
Daedelus—only caught about five minutes of his performance, but it seemed more manic and visceral than the previous times I’ve caught him. His sideburns and threads are still amazing, by the way.
Big regret: missed Mary Anne Hobbs. Many folks I spoke to raved about her brutal dubstep selections, although one notable local DJ said she was awful. He was in the distinct minority, though.
(More reviews after the cut.)
There was more music on offer than ever at this year’s installment of Decibel Festival, Seattle’s internationally renowned annual electronic music massive, and it was just impossible to see it all. I missed a shit-ton of dubstep, including Benga, Boxcutter, and Caspa; the Seattle debut of German deep techno powerhouse the Wighnomy Brothers; and a raved-about afterhours sets from Martyn and Move-D. So it goes. Here are the highlights of what I managed to catch:
At the opening gala at the Seattle Art Museum on Thursday night, Tycho played a sweet set, blissfully ambient but subtly upbeat, performed alternately as one dude hunched behind a heavily-wired laptop and as a trio joined by a guy on guitar and another on Moog synthesizer. Pretty guitar plucking samples swam around head-bobbing beats buoyed by big synth swooshes that reached almost Fred Falke-ian levels of elation.
Truckasauras sounded great at Chop Suey on Saturday, playing some new material for Decibel that showcased a less swung hiphop and more melodic and motirik side of the Truck, marked by forward-pushing 4/4 beats and filter-tweaked arpeggios. Truckasauras' Adam Swan tells me those arpeggios were inspired by heavy listening to Animal Collective's excellent Merriweather Post Pavillion, especially "My Girls." He also reasons that as Foscil's been playing less lately, the Truck fellas have perhaps been funneling more of their songwriting chops into Truck's tracks than before. Whatever it is, it's working.
I’d seen Daedelus before, but never on a sound system with so much insane, gut-busting bass as was at Neumos for the aptly-named Bass Lovers Unite! showcase on Saturday night. The seismic low-end really revealed some startling new depths to dude’s delightfully spazzy sample-mashing sound. The best bits: the seasonally-inappropriate but still anthemic “Fair Weather Friends” (“when the weather gets warm…”), the epic M83 build-up into a soul horn break, Beirut’s “Elephant Gun” pitched up to make Zach Condon’s iconic baritone moan an almost unrecognizably high-spirited chorus, all chopped and spewed over aerobic double-time beats. As always, it was a pleasure watching Daedelus tapping the light-up grid of his Monome, every trigger hit with the most theatrical, wrist-flicking flourish imaginable.
Speaking of spastic, omnivorously sampling sets and hyped-up jazz hands, Gaslamp Killer in Volunteer Park on Sunday was no slouch himself. His fast-paced and unpredictable DJ set spanned from spacey ‘70s jazz funk to dubstep to hiphop to krautrock to Jimi Hendrix to ESG’s perennially sampled “UFO” and all over the place in between, with plenty of charmingly hammy patter on the mic throughout ("I'm gonna take it back to that dirt," he barked at one point. "I psyched you out, motherfuckers...I might take it back to that psychedelic, that depends on you!")
As was the case last year, Decibel went out with a big bang for their closing night on Sunday. Jerry Abstract “killed it” twice—first with relentless, bass-heavy percussive hammering; then by accidentally knocking his laptop clear off its stand, unplugging it and causing a few long minutes of dead air. Tim Exile purveyed his off brand of goofily menacing improvisational beatboxing and live vocal looping (imagine Max Tundra crossed with Jamie Lidell on some harsh acid). The regrettably-named Reagenz (electronic music festivals really do turn up a disproportionately large amount of silly names), played an elegant, understated set of deep-pulsing techno propelled by live drum machinery and analog synths.
The big blow-out, though, came from German techno duo Alter Ego, whose every track deployed monster synth riffs and thick, thumping beats. Standouts included a sped-up, synth-giggling “Jolly Joker”; the pecking, rubbernecking tone bends of “Chicken Shag”; the relentless propulsive rhythm and fried filter squelches of “Beat the Bush”; the enveloping chords of “Gary”; and last but not least, the still unfuckwithable and aptly-titled 2004 anthem “Rocker,” which the duo played with a little extra woodblock (the new “more cowbell”?). As expected, their set tore the place down, a perfectly exhilarating and exhausting end to another outstanding Decibel weekend.

Sometimes you admire music more when you're away from it.
In the '90s, the Manic Street Preachers were ascendant, both creatively, with the gash of 1994's The Holy Bible, and universally, with stadiums and records outselling the ones before, peaking with 1998's triple-platinum This Is My Truth, Tell Me Yours, all while, for the most part, holding onto a reputation as Welsh situationist heroes against an encroaching culture of leisure music.
Back then, we didn't care that much.
We'd always enjoyed The Manics, but found it consistently difficult to latch onto them in the middle of a decade that was already heaving with sounds, brilliance bursting from everyplace. We'd first been exposed to their albums by a friend from across the country, who raved over them in letters and over the phone, periodically sending us discreet cassettes, and who eventually asked us to help out with material for her fanzine, one of the first times we ever wrote about music. Back then, if The Manics were interesting and important, we surrounded ourselves with so much else, not because it was wrong but because it was easy and just as right.
Only when the praise and the crowds died down did we go back and see what we'd missed.
Our reaction was the same as it was this week at Neumo's, where the band kick-started their return to the U.S., almost to the day, in over a decade. Their reason is to promote their latest, this year's Journal For Plague Lovers, based off of the writings of lost guitarist Richey Edwards and backed by a new, uneasy musical grace and no singles. It's here where, the whole night, we kept waiting for a song, any song, we didn't like.
In front of us for the first time, lead-singer James Dean Bradfield reminds us of a militaristic Sam Tyler from BBC's 'Life On Mars'. Drummer Sean Moore seems to have no ego. Bassist, and chief lyricist, Nicky Wire clashes with glam, wearing a white suit-jacket and black eye-shadow, and his sides are flanked by a speaker-stack of stuffed animals and a microphone-stand swirled around with a long, multi-colored feather boa.
Then there are the highlights.
The opener, 1992's "Motorcycle Emptiness". Bradfield doing Nina Persson's bit for 2007's "Your Love Alone Is Not Enough". The drum-machine of "You Stole The Sun From My Heart". An unexpected cover of Camper Van Beethoven's "Take The Skinheads Bowling". Wire leaping about, singing even when it's not his part, as if he's enjoying all this as much as the rest of us.
Halfway through, one of them says, "Richey never made it to Seattle, but I bet he would've loved it. Anywhere that's dark and rainy and pretentious." Adding, after another song, "And I mean pretentious in a good way."
"La Tristesse Durera," "This Joke Sport Severed," "Let Robeson Sing".
In a recent interview, Wire praised "Patience" by Take That.
This is not an ironic choice. It's the greatest comeback single in history. If Neil Young had written it, people would be calling it a masterpiece. I've always liked Take That, too. They looked so brilliant back in the day and did everything right, but this is something else. Gary Barlow is a genius; I won't have anyone argue against him. When Alex Turner slagged off Take That at the 2006 Q awards for getting an award, I nearly lost it. James was grabbing me by the arm, saying: "Don't lose it, Nicky." You get so many alternative bands banging on about how to make perfect pop, and this kicks all their arses.
There's a girl at the back with androgynous hair and colored tape on her face, dancing on her own the entire night, in her ecstatic world of one. She's The Spirit Of The Manics, we think. Still alive. Even after these years.
"Faster," from The Holy Bible, is madness.
"A Design For Life," the finale, breaks our heart.
It's all been a long time coming.
We know we're lucky to hear these songs now that we care and before it was too late, but we also wonder if our lives would've been any different if we'd let them get around to us when we were at the right age.
There's an uncomfortable sincerity about the band, which is difficult for a cynic.
We realize, when we listen to The Manics, live or on record, we listen to something we never had, a different adolescence, one that paid a different sort of attention when the time was ripe, that would've gotten to know people like our friend better, chasing through subways and jumping into cars in the dark, riding around the city together with band t-shirts and the top down, listening to pencil-scribbled cassettes and laughing at plans for the future.
Because there's only a small window to get into things like this, and we've already missed it.

Photo by Phil Rose.

We haven't been in San Francisco in quite a long time, even though we used to live here for ages.
What's new?
1.] A bakery/fish & chips.
2.] A small hut, attached to a liquor store, with a sign that reads "AA Driving School".
3.] The Happy Mondays.
We're at The Regency, which we've never been to before, but it's nice inside. Lots of chandeliers and gold trims. It's a hundred years old. We think shows are somewhat new here. Tonight are The Psychedelic Furs, except let's face it, even though they stand tall with songs like "Love My Way" and Richard Butler, the lead singer, looks like he was having an honestly great time with that characteristic elder-statesmen John Lydon-crossed-with-David-Bowie air and a voice that's always sounded both sad and sarcastic, the band is on the wrong side of the bill.
It's about the Happy Mondays. We're here for the first real U.S. tour in nearly twenty years from the most important Madchester acid-house hedonists of all-time. This is history.
The situation of frontman Shaun Ryder promised a wreck of a show. A lifestyle of rampant alcohol and narcotics, mostly ecstasy and heroin, has left the man shattered and scared. Or, in his own words, just "a scrambled head." Expectations? Low.

It's worse than we feared.
Brother Paul Ryder isn't here. Neither is Bez.
Let's repeat that.
Whoever is on the mixing desk must be goddamn mad about it, too. Tonight's Happy Mondays, no fault of their own, have some of the worst live sound we've ever heard in our lives. Cripes. Despite the handicaps, the band try to lurch out of it, starting with classics like "Kinky Afro," 2007's "Jellybean," and a haggard "Loose Fit," hoping for a semblance of a show but coming up with swamp gas. Ryder is shy, nervous, and barely moving. Worse, he keeps putting his finger in his ear to make sure he's in tune.
Traitor.
Somewhere, though, around a surprise addition of "Reverend Black Grape" by Ryder's spectacular off-shoot Black Grape, the mood spins up. Maybe it's the lyrics, hearing them live for the very first time.
There's nothing more sinister,
As ministers in dresses
Gather round some nice black people,
While I deliver this message
Kill the messsssssage!You do nothing but socialise,
And become a menace
Put on your Reeboks, man,
And go play funky tennisssssss!
No Bez? Really?
Wait! Someone gets around to the boards. The new black female backing vocalist — who appears to have replaced the iconic Rowetta — is stealing the show. And the rest of the band locks on tight, improving with every song, including a new drummer who learned all the songs in six days, until everything peaks with the remix version of "Hallelujah," real mayhem and noise, until, dear lord, that sound. That piano riff.
That "Step On".
One of the most brilliant songs of the 20th century, it's insane tonight, in front of us, all around us, giving you a lump-in-your-throat glimpse, if you squint real hard, of a point in time when a whole generation could be defined by a cross-section of dance and guitar music, both black and white influences, only attitude and a couple of notes, that same piano looping over and over and over.
We don't know how they did it, but they did it.
History saved!
Bez, still at large.
Photo by alternapop.
Reunion shows are often more about the audience than about the band. I wondered how the double reunion bill of Team Dresch and Erase Errata would fare last night, considering that the Vera Project's demographic is unlikely to have been going to shows at the apex of the Riot Grrrl and Queercore movements. ("I was seven!" someone in the crowd gulped, when Jody Bleyle told an anecdote about writing songs in 1994.)

DJ Dewey Decimal and Telepathic Liberation Army set a consistent tone for the night as the audience trickled in, largely queer, largely on bikes. I felt like there should have been more people there, but the consensus in the crowd definitely was 'what a fucking awesome lineup,' with everyone pressing closer and closer to the stage with each subsequent band.
Nothing like seeing an Israeli noise-rock trio on Rosh Hashanah… Bizarrely, this was my first Monotonix live experience (previous attempts to catch them were thwarted by bad timing and scheduling conflicts), and my short response is this: Monotonix are three Dan Deacons with a massive Iggy Pop complex.
But to elaborate: You are much better off seeing Monotonix with no prior knowledge of their shtick. However, due to every blogger and music journalist and YouTube-posting video buff in the world frothing about how spectacularly rambunctious their live performances are, the potential shock and awe Monotonix can deliver is severely diminished.

"Holiday"
"I'm a Loner Dottie, a Rebel..."
"The One You Want"
"Valentine"
"Coming Clean"
"Woodson"
"Overdue"
"Keith Case" (new song)
"Red Letter Day"
"No Love"
"Off the Wagon"
"Campfire Kansas"
"Holy Roman"
"Mass Pike"
"Beer for Breakfast"
"Action & Action"
"Walking on a Wire"
Encore:
"Out of Reach"
"Close to Me" (Cure cover)
"Don't Hate Me"
"Ten Minutes"
(A couple more photos after the jump.)
I just got home from Sunny Day Real Estate's "secret" reunion tour kick-off show at Hell's Kitchen in Tacoma—the show was incredible. The place was packed (though I'm pretty sure everyone who came out got in), and the band sounded phenomenal, playing songs mostly from their first two records (which were just reissued on Sub Pop, BTW).
Here's the setlist:
"Friday"
"Theo B"
"Red Elephant"
Song About an Angel
"Seven"
"Grendel"
"Shadows"
"Iscarabaid"
"5/4"
"Guitars & Video Games"
"J'Nuh"
"Sometimes"
Encore:
"In Circles"
"48"
"Spade & Parade"
Also written on the band's setlist, between "In Circles" and "Sometimes" was this:
"10" (new song)
That's right. They have a new song. Sunny Day Real Estate has a new song. BUT! They didn't end up playing it tonight. They played every song BUT that song. After the show, while mingling with fans outside the club, Dan Hoerner admitted that they chickened out. So "10" could still show up somewhere on this tour... we just won't know when...
Sunny Day plays Vancouver, BC tomorrow and Portland Friday. The Seattle stop isn't until October, so if you're really wanting to see 'em, I promise you, it's worth the three-hour drive in either direction.
I'll post a more thorough review tomorrow. Right now I'm too exhausted and happy to say anything other than OMGTHATWASAWESOMELUVYOUSDRE4EVA!
On stage, the trio exchanged glances, furrowed brows, and other contorted facial expressions. Communicating through this non-verbal language, the musicians crafted freeform musical expanses. Their explorations revealed sparse melodic lines, building up tension gradually before ducking out of the limelight. The trio spared the virtuosic noodling for the crowd; passages developed simply, focusing on a few sonic elements at a time in a lightweight fashion. Brief movements were constructed before giving way to drum breaks, in favor of brevity. The music for the evening was more along the lines of folk, incorporating jazz-styled progressions and occasional waves of drone, noise and dissonance.
The penultimate song for the night featured Sir Richard Bishop, playing something like an Eastern melody, wavering between a few strings and notes. An audience member shaped her hands together to represent a heart and raised it up high, floating her heart upwards above the crowd, and breaking it as the trio crested. The communiqué was well timed, and with the waves of noise and drumming loud as they were in the club, might have been the clearest way to describe the moment.
Apparently, there was some confusion about last night's event at the Showbox, billed as Sneaker Pimps: the World's Largest Sneaker Show and featuring headliners Clipse and Slick Rick supported by a slew of local hip hop acts. A sign at the door said: "If you thought you were buying tickets to Sneaker Pimps the trip hop band refunds are available at point of purchase." Inside the show, a woman asked me in what sounded like a German accent if I was there to see Sneaker Pimps the band (I wasn't, but I may have been a tad under-dressed compared to all the sneaker geeks)—she was, but they'd given her a drink ticket in addition to her refund, so she was hanging around and watching They Live!
There were display racks of different sneaker designs set up along the walls of each bar and onstage, and the house lights were up brighter than your average show so that everyone could get a good look at the shoes. The event was sponsored by a wireless company, and there was one of those screens behind the stage that would display text messages sent to a certain number—two messages from among the many misspelled mash-notes and camera phone photos: "Sad fad" and "RIP dj AM." Fresh Espresso and They Live! both performed abbreviated sets with the high energy they're known for, They Live! joined by a small crew of break-dancers as well as a momentary guest spot from THEE Satisfaction, but the crowd seemed pretty cold to the performances. One performer suggested that the sneaker crowd were too worried about looking sharp and not scuffing their shoes to actually have a good time. I don't get the designer footwear fetish thing (to me, it seems like a bunch of male Carrie Bradshaws), and the whole vibe of the show was just realllllly not my thing, so I ended up splitting before either Slick Rick or Clipse went on. Too bad, because Clipse's set forever ago at Chop Suey killed, and I would have liked to see them again, just under different circumstances.
For the couple songs I caught, Say Hi sounded as good as I've ever seen them, playing as a trio with frontman Eric Elbogen on guitar and vocals backed by a good and rumbling rhythm section. The mix was nice, and Elbogen's voice was more assertive and less mumbly than I remembered. He introduced a song about vampires, and I heard some guy in the crowd ask another guy if he'd seen Twilight yet. He hadn't. A couple kids were making out furiously nearby.
I may have seen the Lonely Forest in passing before—I see a lot of shows—but I'd never really watched the band with a critical eye until just yesterday, something that seemed long overdue given how much praise they've gotten in the press lately. But here's something you haven't heard about the Lonely Forest: they are soooooo boring and average and bland. They make Sunny Day Real Estate sound like the fucking Boredoms. Sure, musically, the Lonely Forest are perfectly competent players, and band-leader John Van Deusen can sing (in fact he tends to really over-sing), but their songs are just the most forgettable kind of big, bloated, radio-ready power pop—all outsized, minor-key melodrama and that over-the-top falsetto signifying emotional depths and heights not really substantiated by trite lyrics ("don't be afraid to live!" "every face reveals a story!" "you're beautiful, but you're in deep!"). This is the kind of stuff you might find in the shallow end of the Twilight soundtrack pool: dickless, arena-aimed indie with mega-church praise-rock band levels of subtlety. The benefit of being so middle of the road, though, is that you get that big, fat hump of the bell curve; when I left after a few songs, there was a long, snaking line of kids waiting in the rain to get in.
Speaking of the big, fat hump of the bell curve, I dropped in for a minute on the Black Eyed Peas afternoon Main Stage set just to confirm that this was a band with absolutely nothing to offer me live. (A colleague suggested that the reason I didn't like the Lonely Forest was that I'm not a 16 year old girl—it's true!—and while at first that seemed like a pretty shaky way to defend a musical act, relativist and condescending, Black Eyed Peas reminded me that, yes, some music is just made for children, and the adults who think like them.) Of course, the band's stage set was gigantic, all lit-up screens and high risers and the band dressed like some bastard child of the Matrix and Public Enemy, the sound was super loud and clear compared to say the Yeah Yeah Yeahs the day before (you didn't even need to go into the stadium to hear the Peas), and they perform with a Disney-like level of professionalism (Fergie no doubt brought some Kids Incorporated discipline to the band when she joined), but yikes. As I was leaving the stadium, Fergie was thanking the audience, in a cartoonishly enthusiastic growl, for making some record or other #1, before launching into the limp, warmed-over (but still immaculately engineered and absurdly polished) ballad "Big Girls Don't Cry," a song about how it's hard "to be a big girl now"—possibly it's a song about the pain of peeing your pants?

Mirah, you are so good! A lot of performers would stagnate after recording and performing for so long— singer/songwriters especially, who might subconsciously feel confined by their form— so it was really exciting to be surprised by your set and to see you taking so many risks. I've seen you perform many times over the years, always thinking you to be one of the Northwest's finest singer/songwriters, but with your high-energy set yesterday, you actually took it to another level.
Gone are the days of softly strumming behind the guitar— Bumbershoot Monday saw Mirah on the microphone, rocking "The Garden" to an electro beat while a super-packed audience nodded their heads.
The cold, overcast weather yesterday seemed to bum the hell out most of the Bumbershoot crowd, which appeared to be the biggest of the weekend, if frustration levels regarding moving from one stage to the other was any gauge. Why the hell was I wearing gloves in early September? Raining and temps in the mid 50s? Summer FAIL. I took it as an ominous sign when I walked onto the Seattle Center grounds while the Minus 5 were covering the Dream Syndicate’s deeply moving Lou Reed-ian classic “Tell Me When It’s Over.” Yes, do tell.
The gloomy climate influenced my choice to check out Akron/Family indoors at KEXP’s Bshoot lounge. I arrived to see the group’s drummer and bassist engaged in a rimshot and tiny tin percussion toy duet, evoking a horse’s canter, while the guitarist strummed a gentle folk motif. Then with little warning, the song erupted into a rumbling, slashing noise rocker somewhere between Neil Young’s “Hey, Hey, My My (Into the Black)” and Mercury Rev’s “Syringe Mouth.” The song, like much of A/F’s material, evolved unpredictably. Metallic percussion solos, abstract noise breakdowns, tribal tom-tom hypnosis, Native American chants, trad alt-country tropes, primal screams all factor into A/F's mongrel approach. One song during A/F’s later set at the Broad Street Stage featured the beat to Sly & the Family Stone’s “Dance to the Music” and warped guitar radiation redolent of ’80s Butthole Surfers. “I think we scared the rain away,” guitarist Seth Olinsky announced, before A/F broke into "Woody Guthrie’s America." Based on what I saw, I’d have to rank Akron/Family Bumbershoot 2009’s second-best act. (See previous Bumbershoot posts to determine #1.)
Another slot in KEXP’s lounge featured Malian guitarist Vieux Farka Touré. Playing an acoustic, he was accompanied by an electric guitarist, bassist, a guy who sat on the floor and tapped what looked like a turtle shell with chopsticks, and a young, long-haired white dude on many percussion implements. Focusing on his new CD, Fondo, Touré and company play a form of blues that relies on brisk, cyclical riffing and complex chording, often augmented by Touré’s plaintive, mildly pained wail. The tunes ramble, undulate, and mesmerize, and mostly end on a dime, to breathtaking effect.

As mentioned some moments ago, Modest Mouse played a great and really nicely balanced set for their headlining, Bumbershoot-closing set in the Memorial Stadium. They didn't hit every song I wanted to hear, of course, but as an old fan, I was pleasantly surprised with how much mid- and early-period stuff they pulled out. And the band (playing as a septet if I counted correctly) sounded great as well, dialed in just right, perfectly loud and clear from dubby bass to cleanly cutting treble.
"The View" and its strobe-lit chorus got the bros really riled up and ready to mosh. The distorted, wildly oscillating guitar solo on "Education" felt really recycled from the latter part of "Tundra/Desert." "Dramamine" still sounds just totally incredible, and the band played it with plenty of judiciously applied feedback on the lead guitar, an extended jam out into a big, noisy crescendo that dropped cliff-like back into that main riff for a coda which say Isaac Brock barking out a little freestyle almost-rap—it was everything I always loved about Modest Mouse's old sets , a little sloppy and feral and combustible, translated without a hitch to the arena. "Dashboard," with its driving beat and trumpet flares, is a big crowd pleaser, eliciting a big wave of hand-clapping along. Brock ended almost every song by barking into the mic then hunching down while holding his guitar up at about face level—an odd (well, maybe not for Brock) flourish.
Seriously, "Satellite Skin is just a painfully mediocre song by MM standards, a slow, dull, utterly unremarkable ballad. Just saying. After that song, Brock delivered some pat banter, asking how everyone was and noting how nice it was to play with Franz Ferdinand, and then he noted, "I'm playing with what I believe to be broken ribs. It fucking sucks, but I did it to myself." They played "Baby Blue Sedan" with a really simple arrangement, and it sounded great, and god damn it was nice to hear such an odd old song. "King Rat" featured a banjo and an airplane flying low overhead above the Space Needle; it was also the song that made me realize how much Brock reminds me of both Calvin Johnson and Frank Black in different ways and at different moments. "Tiny Cities Made of Ashes" began with the guitar seemingly unfixed from the locked-in bass (upright bass, if you're counting) and drums, although it all got into place soon enough. They played an slightly extended intro marked by record scratching guitar strings, and Brock missed the first few words of the first line, picking up around "cities." As the band played the song out, through one extended bridge or breakdown with freestyle rap (god, I'm glad Brock still does these dumb, seemingly improv'd raps) then another, I realized that this song was their latter-day "Tundra/Desert," an easily extendable, anxiously dance-y but still viciously scathing rock jam.
I haven't seen Modest Mouse in maybe a couple years, and I haven't been following their set lists or anything, so this may be totally standard practice, but I was surprised (and stoked) to hear the band launch into the guitars-aflame thrash of "Shit Luck," with its one killer riff and its few lines: "This plane is definitely crashing/this ship is obviously sinking/this building's totally burning down/and my luck is slowly drying up." It's a weird digression on the epic, untouchable Lonesome Crowded West, but it's always made perfect sense in a live set. This evening, Brock kind of abbreviated the last line, omitting the "my, my, my" and just delivering the last line clipped and just a beat early. Next was the still stunning Moon and Antarctica opener "3rd Planet," its chorus—"Your heart...felt good/it was dripping with pitch and made of wood"—just so big and heartfelt and killer. The band played a little Eastern drone fake-out intro to an otherwise simple semi-acoustic treatment of "Wild Pack of Family Dogs."
The band had the briefest false start on "Parting of the Sensory" (is this where they played the little tease of "Life Like Weeds"?), allowing Brock to ask the audience if everyone was okay. Everyone was. And everyone was even better when the band launched into "Float On," a song so legitimately universal and upbeat that it could reasonably bear the Kidz Bop interpretation, its circular chorus just an irresistible sing-along (side note: does the car crash in "Float On"'s lyrics remind anyone else of the auto accident from "Karma's Payment Plan"?) In a perfect world, the band would've followed "Float On" with their early, heartaching breakthrough "Tralier Trash," but instead they understandably played new song "Whale Song," a long, jammy, electric guitar fried, totally crap closer. (Full disclosure: I've been pretty indifferent to the band's stuff since Good News, and I greatly prefer their older material; I just feel like everything since the success of "Float On" has been too safely within the band's established borders, too much a recapitulation of that song's success—hell, "Florida" probably should've just been a Shins song.)
Luckily, even though the house sound engineers brought up some canned music after the end of their proper set, the band returned for an encore, kids totally stoked an freaking out at this almost inevitable occurrence. The band played a slightly rushed and raw (in a good way) version of "Paper Thin Walls," Brock not laughing all the way to the bank so much as spitting there. When that song came out, when Brock had just left Seattle with a bad taste in his mouth, it seemed insanely scathing, and it still kind of does, when it's not busy being totally catchy and oddly upbeat. They closed for reals with "Bury Me With It," a great shout-along which, at least where I was standing, didn't drum up all that much shouting (too bad), the band ending the song with a mighty thrash outro.
I had high hopes for Modest Mouse's set going into Bumbershoot this year, and I had pretty much resigned myself to being at least a little disappointed (and, gasp, maybe even leaving to go see some of Metric), but while it wasn't everything I wanted to hear from the band—that set would be hours long—it was just a fine selection and a fucking fantastic set. I just wish the rain had started coming down in torrents—that would've been perfectly terrible.
Modest Mouse just killed the whole damn festival on the mainstage, and a proper review will be coming soon, but for now, here's the set list, which for my tastes was pretty nicely balanced between new and old—the newest was "Satellite Skin," the oldest was "Dramamine"—with an emphasis on material from The Moon and Antarctica:
"Gravity Rides Everything"
"The View"
"Education"
"Dramamine"
"Dashboard"
"Satellite Skin"
"Baby Blue Sedan"
"King Rat"
"Tiny Cities Made of Ashes"
"Shit Luck"
"3rd Planet"
"Wild Pack of Family Dogs"
"Parting of the Sensory"
"Float On"
"Whale Song"
(encore)
"Paper Thin Walls"
"Bury Me With It"