Visual Art
A Balancing Act
Seattle Art Museum
Wed–Sun. Through April 11.
The Adoration of Alexander Calder
Grappling with the Good Cheer of the Maker of the Mobile
Post a comment »
In/Visible
JEN GRAVES'S WEEKLY CONVERSATION WITH PEOPLE IN ART
This Week: Sylvia Wolf Talks
Recently in Visual Art
The Frightful Power of the Camera
Meiro Koizumi, an Artist to Very Seriously Watch (and Watch Out For)
2 comments »
Hairless Romantics
Maria Friberg's Existential Videos and Photographs at the Nordic Heritage Museum
Post a comment »
Visual Art Picks
-
American Glass: How Soon is Now?/Signals
Traver Gallery (Tacoma)
Nov 14 - Dec 6 -
I Do
Cupcake Royale
Nov 1 - Dec 31 -
In the Heat of the Night
Pratt Fine Arts Center
Nov 14 (till further notice) -
Gravity
Cornish College of the Arts Main Gallery
Nov 3 - Dec 11 -
The Corner of Sweet and Bitter
Open Satellite
Nov 10 - Jan 9 - All Visual Art Events »
Visual Art Links
-
Blogs
- Anaba
- Another Bouncing Ball
- Art and Politics Now
- Artdish
- ARTicles
- Artworld Salon
- Best Of
- C-Monster
- Culturegrrl
- Dangerous Chunky
- Douglas Britt in the Houston Chronicle
- Edward Winkleman (NY)
- Fallon & Rosof (Philly)
- Getting To Know You Better
- Grammar Police
- Greg Allen
- I Call It Oranges
- Looking Around (TIME Magazine's Richard Lacayo)
- Modern Art Notes (Tyler Green)
- Peripheral Vision
- PORT (Portland)
- The Art Law Blog
- Vroom Journal
- Museum/Organization Blogs
- Aggregators
- Publications
Art & Architecture on
Visual Art
Thursday, November 5, 2009
Visual Art Whatcom Museum to Open With 'Elephant Beds'
Posted by Jen Graves on Thu, Nov 5, 2009 at 3:04 PM
The Whatcom Museum in Bellingham is opening a new building next weekend, designed by Olson Sundberg Kundig Allen, and dubbed the Lightcatcher for its elliptical 34-foot-long wall of glass. Images of the building are here.
John Grade—he of the biodegradable, buried, wind-whipped, canyon-residing, glacier-sitting sculptures—has the major opening exhibition in the 26-foot-high gallery. It's called Elephant Beds, and it's inspired by the microscopic algae that formed the white cliffs of Dover.
An enlarged version of it premiered at Fabrica in Brighton this summer: 20 white bell-shaped objects suspended from filaments hung in the deconsecrated church. Over time, half of them descended into a pool of ink, where they disintegrated (they are made of water-degradable corn-based polymer and paper). At the end of the exhibition, the other half were marched down the road and straight into the English Channel.
In Bellingham, the installation is half as large: Five will descend into ink; the other five will be walked into Bellingham Bay. Grade hopes he'll be able to get video of them underwater this time; in the English Channel the waves were too powerful. The Bellingham walk will take place April 10, after they've been in the gallery for five months.
Here's a video of the installation underway in Bellingham; awesome images from Brighton on the jump.
Bloom: The Elephant Bed Install from Ian Gill on Vimeo.
Arts / City / Visual Art / Genius Genius Is Coming! Genius Is Coming!
Posted by Jen Graves on Thu, Nov 5, 2009 at 1:00 PM
I'm getting excited for the party at the Moore on the 13th, in part because MY GENIUS (I call him this only because he's the visual art Genius, not because I selected him alone: we pick as a committee) IS THE BEST GENIUS.
Oh yeah. I'm throwing it down for Jeffry Mitchell. He will WHUP all you other Geniuses, like Wesley Willis whupped Batman's ass!
Okay, I'm just talking shit. But I did come across this adorable photograph of Jeffry making a drawing of Gretchen Bennett last week.
And need I remind you of Ellen Ziegler's Jeffry tribute?
Visual Art Currently Hanging: Ryan Molenkamp, Sharon Arnold, and Trevor Johnson
Posted by Jen Graves on Thu, Nov 5, 2009 at 10:26 AM
Each artist is a resonator for the others. Molenkamp's paintings look like they reveal scaffoldings of unseen sedimentary deposits all around us, whole cities whose scale is always shifting. Johnson's carved Styrofoam universes jutting out from the wall are alternative maps to the same sort of indeterminate locations. It is not clear where they've been cut and where they've been torn, and the odd breaks of the surfaces resemble ice floes. They cast dark, jagged shadows.
Meanwhile, Arnold's delicate works are bright and light, at risk of floating off if they weren't pinned to the wall and grounded by their own heartbeats. Their rhythms are created by repetitive motions: the sewing of soft, hairy yarns in rows on hundreds of feet of fragile cash-register paper, hung in half-unspooled rolls on the wall; the cutting away of dozens of strips of paper to reveal, curtain-like or hair-like, the wall beneath the paper.
It is a tight, teeming universe in there. These are images shot during the installation. But as (almost) always, you have to see it to get it.
Wednesday, November 4, 2009
Visual Art Raining Rectangles
Posted by Jen Graves on Wed, Nov 4, 2009 at 2:19 PM
In this morning's art walk list, I inadvertently left off Ken Kelly's torrential new works at Howard House. I love looking at them in a long row.
The Seattle artist recently had a serious hospitalization and could use a little love—come out and support him at the opening tomorrow.
Visual Art Camouflage Paintings Made by Censorship
Posted by Jen Graves on Wed, Nov 4, 2009 at 1:21 PM
When the Dutch government didn't want Google Earth showing satellite images of military installations, it censored them—stylishly, in camo, as if they were paintings-by-number.
Greg Allen plans to paint them (isn't there a digital way? he asks), and he posts a number of the enticing-looking things, with a further link to even more of them here.
This is my favorite, the plump treetops almost indistinguishable from the bloaty dots.
Visual Art The Easy Way, and the Hard Way
Posted by Jen Graves on Wed, Nov 4, 2009 at 12:12 PM
Do not tell SuttonBeresCuller that it was such a breeze for this nice German fellow to convert an old gas station into a clean, usable property. Boys, just keep going: We are rooting for you.
Visual Art Linda Mendelson of Seattle, Are You Out There?
Posted by Jen Graves on Wed, Nov 4, 2009 at 10:53 AM
This was the gambit, and it looks like PUNCH came away at least with a few bucks (I hope).
Visual Art Currently Hanging
Posted by Jen Graves on Wed, Nov 4, 2009 at 10:13 AM

The Henry Art Gallery owns only 10 of Allan Sekula's 30 WTO protest photographs. owns all 30 of Allan Sekula's WTO protest photographs, and is only showing 10 because of limited wall space on the mezzanine. Then don't use the mezzanine! The full set should be up.
That complaint aside, even with just 10 we get a chance to see how heroically Sekula set out to be Zen about the protests. Meaning: he didn't want to overlay anything on the scene. He wanted to see it.
That meant shots like the one above, where absolutely everything is glass and nothing is direct—so different from smoke-and-carnival shots that it stands out as a moment of unsettling silence. Because the businessmen are behind glass, we're extra-aware that the photographer is behind the glass of the camera's lens. The photograph is disturbing precisely because it so aggressively suppresses physical contact, perfectly capturing the fear of it erupting.
On display with the photographs is Sekula's letter describing how he thought about this work. It says:
In photographing the Seattle demonstrations my working idea was to move with the flow of protest, from dawn to 3 a.m. if need be, taking in the lulls, the waiting and the margin of events. The rule of thumb for this sort of anti-journalism: no flash, no telephoto lens, no gas mask, no auto-focus, no press pass and no pressure to grab at all costs the one defining image of dramatic violence.Later, working at the light-table, and reading the increasingly stereotypical descriptions of the new face of protest, I realized all the more that a simple descriptive physiognomy was warranted. The alliance on the streets was indeed stranger, more varied and inspired than could be conveyed by the cute alliterative play with “teamsters” and “turtles.”
I hoped to describe the attitudes of people waiting, unarmed, sometimes deliberately naked in the winter chill, for the gas and the rubber bullets and the concussion grenades. There were moments of civic solemnity, of urban anxiety, and of carnival.
Again, something very simple is missed by descriptions of this as a movement founded in cyberspace: the human body asserts itself in the city streets against the abstraction of global capital. There was a strong feminist dimension to this testimony, and there was also a dimension grounded in the experience of work. It was the men and women who work on the docks, after all, who shut down the flow of metal boxes from Asia, relying on individual knowledge that there is always another body on the other side of the sea doing the same work, that all this global trade is more than a matter of a mouse-click.
One fleeting hallucination could not be photographed. As the blast of stun grenades reverberated amidst the downtown skyscrapers, someone with a boom box thoughtfully provided a musical accompaniment: Jimi Hendrix’s mock-hysterical rendition of the American national anthem. At that moment, Hendrix returned to the streets of Seattle, slyly caricaturing the pumped-up sovereignty of the world’s only superpower.
At the Henry, which is also featuring Stranger columnist Christopher DeLaurenti's surprisingly musical recording created from field recordings of the protests. It sounds unlikely, but this used to be the only recording I could write to. I know it inside and out, and it really is a marvel.
There's also a Flickr pool called Henry WTO+10 where you can add your own photos from the protests.
More of Sekula's WTO images here.
Visual Art Jack Daws's Golden Penny Is Found
Posted by Jen Graves on Wed, Nov 4, 2009 at 9:37 AM
Essentially, he gave away a hundred dollars in gold. It was entirely possible that nobody would ever discover the sculpture in their chunk of change.
But somebody did—and the person who did is an artist, and a maker of cakes, including one with the face of a penny. It's a pretty great little story. The artist tells it in her own words on the jump.
Visual Art It's First Thursday, Y'all
Posted by Jen Graves on Wed, Nov 4, 2009 at 9:13 AM
Tomorrow's Artwalk includes (click to enlarge)
Bill Finger's 1972, age 12 at PUNCH
Nola Avienne's eida (steel, magnets, metal, shoe polish, and blood) at SOIL
Drew Daly's Float 1, Float 2, and Float 3 at Greg Kucera
Mary Ann Peters's taganga at James Harris
and Stranger Geniuses SuttonBeresCuller's works-in-progress-that-will-be-completed at Lawrimore Project
Tuesday, November 3, 2009
Visual Art An Attempt to Duplicate the Bilbao Effect Near Guernica
Posted by Jen Graves on Tue, Nov 3, 2009 at 3:25 PM
Last week, NYT architecture critic Nicolai Ouroussoff declared this epoch over. And that's not such a bad thing. It was exciting, writing about all those buildings. But so much money was sunk into buildings that funders forgot that they were also supposed to pay for, you know, art and its plain old maintenance (not to mention, in many cases, for the care and feeding of buildings after they're built).
But today comes the news that the Bilbao Guggenheim is considering trying to revive another depressed town using the museum-as-medicine treatment, this time near Guernica in a place called Urdaibai. It's being sold as a "green" project, but not everybody's buying it...
Visual Art Jonathan Raban on Dorothea Lange
Posted by Jen Graves on Tue, Nov 3, 2009 at 2:07 PM
This is painfully evident in Washington state, where I live. Were Lange to return here with her camera seventy years on, it would not be a Rip Van Winkle experience so much as a numbing sense of déjà vu. The cities and suburbs would be unrecognizable to her, but the poverty in the countryside created by the corporate agricultural system would yield material for photographs identical to those she took in 1939. There are small, Spanish-speaking farm towns on the Columbia plateau where the average per capita income is still in the middling four figures.In summer, migrant fruit pickers pile into the Columbia and Yakima valleys, living in camps little different, and hardly more affluent, than the one where Lange found Florence Thompson. And inventive new ways of being poor continue to emerge. In Forks, at the foot of the Olympic National Park, there are run-down trailer parks on the edges of the town, inhabited by "brushpickers," mostly Guatemalan, who make a tenuous living by scavenging in the woods for the moss, ferns, beargrass, and salal used by florists around the world to add greenery to bouquets.
Migrant Mother has become the symbol of a now-remote decade, to which the passage of years has lent a period glow. Yet across the rural West the Great Depression is less a historical event than a permanent condition, which existed before the 1930s and is still there now, though it shifts from place to place and fluctuates in its severity. The warning in the rearview mirror applies here: the lives in Lange's photographs for the FSA are closer than they may appear.
Monday, November 2, 2009
Visual Art Currently Hanging
Posted by Jen Graves on Mon, Nov 2, 2009 at 11:51 AM
When Josh Faught was announced as this year's Betty Bowen Award winner, I asked: Who is this guy? Since 2007 he has lived and taught in Eugene, Oregon, and he has never shown any work in Seattle or Portland, as far as I know (he did show some drawings at the Helm Gallery in Tacoma, but I missed them).
Last week I interviewed him (podcast coming) and got to Seattle Art Museum to see his work, and at this point I agree with jamey marie braden: breath of fresh air for realz! His work is warm and sad and lonely and expectant—political and physical.
Here's Endless Night, the 2008 work that's installed at SAM.
At SAM the installation is a little different than here. The fighting burst of light coming from the pink candle on the old-fashioned chamberstick is not on the left, as pictured, but on an adjacent wall from the other "windows." The sorry-looking rolled-up window that stands in the corner here is next to it (Faught calls this freak flag a "failed" textile), tied with a ribbon that reads "Not Your Bag."
These windows are a series of loose afghans made of crocheted yarn dipped in indigo dye. Strings stream down their faces like rain.
They're taken from 60s/70s patterns, but this is not what the patternmakers intended. The designs have been scaled up and the afghans are wrapped around garden trellises, their sides unevenly scalloped from the poking edges of the wood. They're the size of paintings, but where painted canvases would be stapled neatly to stretchers, these wear fat scars of imperfect handstitching.
There's nostalgia here for sure: you're not just standing in front of a dark window to wait for something to happen, but remembering how it felt to stand in front of a dark window. What could have occurred? It feels like this nostalgic past might yet turn out differently.
When I interviewed Faught, we talked some about politics. About the way his work is urgently political, how it analogizes being gay in a straight world and working with fabric in the art world. How it deals with issues of sagginess and solidity in sculpture. Signs of nervous hands versus signs of mastery in craft. Most artists outsource labor to hire somebody skilled; Faught uses shaky assistants.
He grew up in a suburb of St. Louis, a placid place haunted by suburban-style threats (toxic chemicals! sex predators!), and there's a tender acknowledgment of fear and disruption in what he makes. Triage (2009) is a patchwork tapestry painted with nail polish, wearing political pins and a row of self-help books in sewn pockets. You Can't Live Scared (2007) is a dark, webby weaving hung next to a Super-8 film of the artist trying to read an explicit personals ad while climbing, naked, into the bathtub.
I wish those were here at SAM; I'm all eyes at this point. I'm fantasizing about a Northwest queerness show already, with Faught, Jeffry Mitchell, Matthew Offenbacher, Eli Hansen…
Here's a good interview with Faught by the Museum of Contemporary Craft, and some images of work he had in the recently closed show Call + Response.
Wednesday, October 28, 2009
Visual Art The Business of No Monkey-Business
Posted by Jen Graves on Wed, Oct 28, 2009 at 1:05 PM
He turned to photography—to photographing other outcasts. He started at home, in Buffalo's poorest neighborhoods. He worked in collaboration with the subjects he found.
The only thing I asked them was to look at the camera. I liked it when I saw their eyes, and that's when I knew I was ready to make their picture. When you look at these pictures, you know there was no monkey-business, and that I was not sneaking around trying to steal pictures of people. To make a photograph in this way is an act of respect.A slide show of Rogovin's work narrated by him, along with a short appreciation by Randy Kennedy, appeared on New York Times photo blog Lens in August; Rogovin will turn 100 in December, and a big party is planned in Buffalo.
Here in Seattle, 40 of Rogovin's works were recently donated to the Henry Art Gallery collection. A show is coming up.
Visual Art 'Lips and Eyeballs Have Been Getting a Lot of Attention'
Posted by Jen Graves on Wed, Oct 28, 2009 at 12:49 PM
Here's Adrian Searle walking by, then going inside, this London spectacle. The art is a lady, her poodle, an ear couch, nose sconces, some flowers, some chocolates, and 1940s Vogues. Baldessari is the best, but I don't know about this.
Sex / Visual Art 'If it makes a guy happy to chop his willy off then fine, but what's wrong with putting on dresses and still being a man?'
Posted by Jen Graves on Wed, Oct 28, 2009 at 10:27 AM
Visual Art Fun with Public Sculpture
Posted by Jen Graves on Wed, Oct 28, 2009 at 9:46 AM
Peter Shelton, whose work cloudsandclunkers is a really nice moment at Sea-Tac Airport

managed to install a pig on its side at LAPD headquarters—and the cops noticed. Tee hee.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009
Visual Art / Architecture Lawrence Halprin, R.I.P.
Posted by Jen Graves on Tue, Oct 27, 2009 at 5:43 PM
Lawrence Halprin, Freeway Park Viewing Base, 1976Freeway Park is like a craggy mountain on its head; the summit is at the bottom. You climb down elaborate descending stairs to stand on a narrow plane with a bracing view. But this isn't a vista. You face an ugly metal screen. A thin slice of waterfall rushes in front of it, falling from the top of the park. Through the water and the metal, you can see the subject you came all this way to look at: cars flying by under an orangey electric light, inside the concrete tunnel of Interstate 5. It's as if the park were here first, and then the city sprung up around it, interrupted it, completed it.
This fellow's photographs of Freeway Park and Halprin's other works are terrific. Mr. Mudede loves Freeway park, too.
Visual Art / Fashion Currently Standing
Posted by Jen Graves on Tue, Oct 27, 2009 at 12:36 PM
A few weeks ago I visited the recently reopened Henry Art Gallery's collections study center—meaning, storage. (You can, too—just have a reason and make an appointment.)
It's worth it for the shelves and shelves of shoes alone. Some are out in the galleries now, thanks to the awesomely eclectic Vortexhibition Polyphonica. There are red 1970s women's sandals with retractable roller skates by Omnia/C, outrageously 1980s sexy red pumps made in Taiwan, Han shoes for bound feet, the Manchu answer to binding (hell, no!), and these, called qabqab:
They're made of wood with inlaid mother of pearl, and that architectural understructure is solid metal. They're marked as from the Ottoman Empire, probably made in Syria, 19th-century. And the label explains women wore them to keep from getting their feet wet at the bathhouses (Venetian women later wore them, to protect from the city's rising tides...).
Here they are in action (photo from Wiki).
Visual Art / Books The Agonizing Pleasure of Unwrapping
Posted by Jen Graves on Tue, Oct 27, 2009 at 10:54 AM
When he complained about this to a friend of Patti Smith's (who he was living with at the time at the Chelsea Hotel), she suggested he make his own porn. She had a Polaroid camera, it was instant, he could look at what he was making while he was making it; why didn't he use it?
And that's how Robert Mapplethorpe became a photographer.
Sylvia Wolf tells the story about her discovery of Mapplethorpe's Polaroids in a podcast I recorded with her last week—and along with the exhibition at the Henry, there's also a book I want to mention.
The book has its own external wrapper, in a nod to what Wolf describes as the "agonizingly pleasurable experience" of "inviting suspense and withholding gratification"—something central to Mapplethorpe's art.
The book has a few great attributes. First, the plates in it are basically the same size as the actual Polaroids, because the Polaroids are so small (4 by 5 at the largest). So you can spend hours studying them at more or less the correct scale, which is a beautiful thing (there is so much loss in typical art books!).But in addition to that, the book also has many images that are not in the exhibition. Some of these are owned by the Guggenheim and couldn't travel to Seattle, but others are absent from the exhibition for a more interesting reason: only the negatives still exist. (Early on, making Polaroids included separating the print from the negative and coating it with a fixing solution.)
There is a whole languorous-Muybridge-like sequence of self-portraits in which Mapplethorpe approaches a hanging robe, puts it on, takes it off, and faces the camera nude—wraps and unwraps himself—that can only be found in the book. The prints are lost. Wolf tried to find them, but, failing that, the Mapplethorpe Foundation agreed to allow plates to be made for the book from the negatives. I wish I could show them to you here. You just have to get the book, unwrap it, and look.
Monday, October 26, 2009
Visual Art Currently Hanging
Posted by Jen Graves on Mon, Oct 26, 2009 at 1:24 PM
Friday night in Seattle art was extraordinary. Hundreds of people showed up for the Henry Art Gallery's bash stuffed with art, which is where I was (making this bad decision), and I heard from several people that the Betty Bowen Award talks across town at SAM by Josh Faught, Matthew Offenbacher, and Jenny Heishman were extra-great.
Inside the front door at the Henry is a show that people passed right by, in the darkened room that was once the bookstore and gift shop. The clumsiest possible impression of a romantic seaside scene is created. A canoe sits on supports on the floor. Under it, a department-store fan, a silvery-blue garland, a clear Plexiglas box, and a couple of footlights make reflective magic, sending "moonlit" "water" skittering and shimmering across the wood floor and the empty retail shelves.
Standing inside the canoe are two life-sized cutouts of Seattle artists Jenny Zwick and Joe Park. Videos of the artists, dressed as doppelgangers and playing and singing a duet, are projected onto the cutouts. The song they're doing is "Tonight You Belong to Me," made famous by the beach scene with Steve Martin and Bernadette Peters in The Jerk. In the movie, he whips out a ukulele and she a cornet; here, she's on guitar and he plays a melodica. The sweetness and comedy are underscored by the fact that the silly twinkling across the floor and shelves is actually kind of transporting.
Friday, October 23, 2009
Visual Art Really.
Posted by Jen Graves on Fri, Oct 23, 2009 at 11:31 AM
Yesterday I caught four new shows at the Henry, and they're being celebrated tonight with a great big party you should not miss:
Eirik Johnson's poetic yet clear-eyed photographs of how the lumber industry has shaped our regional landscape.
Ten of Allan Sekula's "anti-photojournalistic shots" of the WTO protests with his letter explaining why and how he approached the event.
A giant collections show including wild shoes and a gorgeous corset from the extensive and never-seen fashion holdings of the museum.
And almost 100 Robert Mapplethorpe Polaroids (max size is 4 by 5 inches) hung in tender pairs. This show is irresistible.

Also tonight will be performances at The Gift Shop, Seattle artist Matthew Offenbacher's ongoing installation inside the Henry. Somehow it will involve Joe Park (seated) and Jenny Zwick, doing something that might look like this.
Visual Art Leibovitz's Obamas
Posted by Jen Graves on Fri, Oct 23, 2009 at 10:49 AM
What I'm seeing in this photo (first referenced in Morning News) is the art. What are those paintings? They are strategically covered. And look at that white person who snuck in!

Visual Art Currently Hanging
Posted by Jen Graves on Fri, Oct 23, 2009 at 10:10 AM
Tucked in the back of SOIL Art Gallery is a video by Peter Nelson called On Dying. It's simple: one talking head at a time on a stark white background, each person telling a short story. The voices are of old men and women talking about dying—remembering siblings who committed suicide or died in accidents, their expectations for their own deaths ("Heaven will be better."), their struggles to figure out how and where to sleep after husbands and wives die.
But there is a central disconnect. The faces "speaking" these words are young—not children, but people in their twenties, people whose voices should not sound like this and people who do not have these stories to tell.
The stark background isolates the faces and the sounds as the only elements, throwing the tension into immediate relief; there's nothing else to consider. At first you think: These people are acting; what good actors! Then you realize this is not quite the case, that they are not actually speaking but only lip-syncing. The audio-video synchronization, under scrutiny, is noticeably imperfect. But it is also close enough to be uncanny. These "actors"—friends of the artist—have become possessed. They seem to be telling themselves things they will need to know eventually.
Nelson, a photo and video grad student at UW, also has an entire solo show at 4Culture this month. It's called Former Best Friends Forever and is based on his interviews with his own former actual best friends from various periods in his life, represented in the gallery in recordings playing in discrete settings—inside the cab of a Chevy pickup parked in the gallery, on headphones at a work desk. His former BFFs are variously gruntled and disgruntled.
Tuesday, October 20, 2009
Arts / Visual Art Today's Layoffs at LA Times Include Arts Writer, Or, A Further Exploration of Stupid Fucking Credulous Hackery in Arts Journalism
Posted by Jen Graves on Tue, Oct 20, 2009 at 6:49 PM
This afternoon comes the news that Diane Haithman is out. No word yet on whether more culture staffers will be involved in the round, or how big and bad the round will be.
When these things happen, it's always the general-assignment arts writers who get cut, not the critics—the writers who do more of the getting-the-word-out work, not the name writers. Of course, this makes a certain amount of intrinsic sense, and I'm not arguing with it. Name writers like Christopher Knight or Christopher Hawthorne are name writers for a reason, and I'd argue that they do more to get the word out than anyone.
But I'm not necessarily in the majority on that one when it comes to the philosophy of arts journalism.
Yesterday I finally finished watching all the presentations and roundtables from the National Arts Journalism Summit that took place a few weeks ago in LA (YouTube channel with everything here), and I heard repeatedly in the projects that the summit organizers chose as examples of innovative arts journalism that criticism is really not all that important. Mark Mangan of Flavorpill summed it up neatly: "We only write about what we like." You have limited time in your life; why would you want to spend it reading about something the writer does not like, he said.
Jim Gaines of Flyp Media, put it even more pointedly when he said the place for the critic is on blogs. By contrast, "What we are selling, what we are attempting to create is engagement," he said. (I know we print types are slow to adapt, and I know we critics can be jerks—but as if we're not interested in engagement? Why did we get into this??)
In all the demo videos and conversations, I did find some things totally chastening and totally inspiring. For instance, I'm not using design or video almost at all to present stories and reviews, and that seems downright dumb. There were broader ideas, too, that I'm still considering, about attitude and approach. And the online editor of the Cedar Rapids Gazette, Steve Buttry, gave me the chills with his speech about the larger project of newspapers. "News, community connection, meaning, connection to the marketplace: those are our product, not ink on paper." I could get down with all of that—except the "connection to the marketplace" part makes me nervous. But I think he was saying that any web site has to be entrepreneurial, not that writers have to cover all those goals themselves, and I totally appreciate that. (The Stranger has been moving away from the traditional advertising-based model for some time, and that's part of why we still have jobs.)
But I still want to put in a plug for the value of criticism. The other day, when I dubbed The Seattle Times a "Stupid Fucking Credulous Hack" for promoting Seattle Art Museum's promotion of what is truly a thin Michelangelo show using a David replica, people got all over me for being overly serious and grouchy.
But if a newspaper put a cardboard cutout advertising a crappy big-budget movie on its front page rather than reviewing the movie in that space, wouldn't you notice? That's what the Times did, and I still say it was a sham. Several days later, the Times buried Gayle Clemans's fine review of the Michelangelo show inside the paper, as if to say that the promotion was more important than the review.
But which did more service to the reader? While the promotion touted the show, the review warned those about to pay SAM's $15 suggested donation that the show is only worth only a fraction of those bucks.
I was at the museum with Clemans during the press preview, so I know that she saw the exhibition before the Times splashed it on the front page. She easily could have told editors—uh, guys, this show isn't worth the hype.
But Clemans is not full-time at the paper, so front-page editors probably wouldn't even have cared. That's because the Times slashed its art critic position last year.
So, folks: That's stupid fucking credulous hackery in the field of arts journalism. No, nobody is going to die or be sent to prison for it. But it sucks nonetheless.























RSS