Line Out Music & Nightlife


News & Arts

« If You're in a Band READ THIS | Just cause. »

Tuesday, February 12, 2008

In Defense of Idiot Pilot and Phil Collins

posted by on February 12 at 13:07 PM

I know, I can’t believe I’m defending them either. But in January Eric asked me if there was anything I wish I would have said or revised from 2007 and my answer was actually Idiot Pilot. I wished I would have said something nice about how their new album was significantly better than their old one (though still not great). I thought Wolves came out months ago. Turns out it was released today.

Anyone remember when Pitchfork called Idiot Pilot ďthe musical equivalent of a monkey with a hand grenade?Ē That was somewhat fitting for their debut album Strange We Should Meet Here, an abrasive, unfortunate amalgamation of Radiohead and the Blood Brothers full of glitchy beats and inappropriate screaming. Though it catapulted the band into Major Label buzz and world tours its praise was mostly given by people too young to buy beer.

I was legitimately surprised by their follow up Wolves. Comparing both releases, their growth as songwriters is obvious: Strange is high school and Wolves is college. Much of the inappropriate screaming has been removed; in fact most of the Blood Brothers vibe has been wiped clean. Michael Harris will draw Thom Yorke comparisons until the end of his career, which isnít particularly a bad thing since its obvious that’s just the way his voice sounds - he’s not stealing any of Yorke’s stylings. It’s also much more effective when itís not contrasted with screamo. Instead, bandmate Daniel Anderson has focused his attention on writing huge arena rock anthems deriving from an obvious love of classic U2. The result is an interesting one Ė grown up music targeted at children. While it’s nowhere near a complete success it is vastly superior to their debut album, which if anything is a strong step in the right direction for the band. At least itís less likely to get them booed off the stage at Neumos again. I give it 2 and ĺ stars.

As far as Phil Collins goes, I canít (and wonít) try to defend his music. Or his actions. But there is an excellent episode of This American Life where he is consulted on heartbreak and breakups and he actually comes across as a nice, likable guy. It definitely raised my opinion of the man. It also reminded me how much I like the Bonnie Raitt song “I Can’t Make You Love Me.”

RSS icon Comments


also drummed on many a mike oldfield album, AND produced Frida's "I Know There's Something Going On". he's also been in studio with eno on a number of albums, so the man must be respected for the drumming thing.

He makes crap music alone, but early genesis and his production work is great.

just sayin'.

Posted by terry miller | February 12, 2008 1:22 PM

A band got booed off the stage at Neumos?

Do tell...

Posted by E | February 12, 2008 1:39 PM

That was the word from a good friend of mine who said she saw it go down at a show they opened up for Minus the Bear a few years ago.

Posted by Jeff Kirby | February 12, 2008 1:49 PM

It happened! I was there!

Posted by Ari Spool | February 12, 2008 1:51 PM


Posted by Eric Grandy | February 12, 2008 2:32 PM

you idiots need a pilot -- i'll take IP over MTB any day/night! some fool in the audiences hisses and you say they were "booed off stage"?! nice work

Posted by idiotz | February 12, 2008 3:29 PM

Oh, dude. People weren't just hissing. There was a ton of people up on the balcony and in the middle of the crowd booing and yelling, "You suck!" Because, when you are Idiot Pilot, and you go on between Fall of Troy and Minus the Bear for some reason [cough cough major label cough cough], people are going to get angry about how they paid a lot to not see crap.

They didn't leave the stage, but they probably should have.

Have they even played Seattle since that show?

Posted by Ari Spool | February 12, 2008 3:46 PM

Man, that whole bill sounds like balls. In fact, I think I was at that show, but every time I try to remember it I just slip into a petite mal seizure.

Posted by Eric Grandy | February 12, 2008 4:36 PM

That episode of This American Life is my favorite. I actually listened to it Sunday just after my Valentines day date told me she couldn't go out with me... ever.

Posted by Little Red Ryan Hood | February 12, 2008 10:04 PM

Comments Closed

In order to combat spam, we are no longer accepting comments on this post (or any post more than 14 days old).